Rendered at 16:55:07 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Cloudflare Workers.
spicyusername 2 hours ago [-]
Out of curiosity, what are the "plausibly harmful things" that working at a frontier lab will cause that working at other companies will not cause?
I recognize there is a lot of AI, and by extension frontier lab, dissent,
just curious to hear the distilled arguments from AI and frontier Lab dissenters.
Is it a copyright thing?
An economic collapse thing?
An anti-datacenter thing?
An "I don't like the way the CEO's moral compasses are" thing?
Something else?
All of the above?
34 minutes ago [-]
qgin 33 minutes ago [-]
Even the most optimistic people working in the field think there's a pretty reasonable chance of things going extremely badly.
bagacrap 25 minutes ago [-]
As the author puts it,
> x-risk
That would be short for existential risk. I mean did you read the Anthropic S1? The stated risks are not, like, "we go bankrupt".
trescenzi 3 hours ago [-]
The rationalist community is fascinating to me in how deeply disconnected it is from the world as a whole. Of course this is true of many religious, or quasi-religious, communities but the name always tricks me briefly.
I say this because this line is startling to me: "There should be some voices of general disapproval, and there is much value in saying socially aggressive and unpleasant true things."
It's not startling in that I disagree with it. It's startling because _some voices of general disapproval_ is mentioned as if the majority of the US doesn't disapprove of AI development. If the votes against data center development do not convince you of this because you believe it's just NIMBYism, then here's one poll from earlier this year[1].
All that said I do not disagree. There needs to be strong voices of disapproval as this is a fundamentally authoritarian technology seeking to concentrate the knowledge of humanity into the hands of a few.
These are young people living in the SF tech bubble echo chamber. Obviously if they traveled the country on a listening tour, this blogpost might be unnecessary.
As someone who has seen about a dozen colleagues join frontier AI labs, my small sample size observation has been: young people without families quickly become indoctrinated in the cult. Established heads of household bounce within a year. I think if you are younger, with fewer connections to the outside world, then you are (a) less risk averse (this is biological fact) and (b) have less to lose (existential risk does not affect you the same way as someone with children) and (c) are easier to brainwash because you are more socially isolated (watch any documentary about how cults form).
bagacrap 24 minutes ago [-]
> Their job is giving them silly amounts of money and validation and prestige.
Can just stop right there. No need to keep brainstorming.
> It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it.
I recognize there is a lot of AI, and by extension frontier lab, dissent, just curious to hear the distilled arguments from AI and frontier Lab dissenters.
Is it a copyright thing? An economic collapse thing? An anti-datacenter thing? An "I don't like the way the CEO's moral compasses are" thing? Something else? All of the above?
> x-risk
That would be short for existential risk. I mean did you read the Anthropic S1? The stated risks are not, like, "we go bankrupt".
I say this because this line is startling to me: "There should be some voices of general disapproval, and there is much value in saying socially aggressive and unpleasant true things."
It's not startling in that I disagree with it. It's startling because _some voices of general disapproval_ is mentioned as if the majority of the US doesn't disapprove of AI development. If the votes against data center development do not convince you of this because you believe it's just NIMBYism, then here's one poll from earlier this year[1].
All that said I do not disagree. There needs to be strong voices of disapproval as this is a fundamentally authoritarian technology seeking to concentrate the knowledge of humanity into the hands of a few.
1: https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2026/03/12/key-findi...
As someone who has seen about a dozen colleagues join frontier AI labs, my small sample size observation has been: young people without families quickly become indoctrinated in the cult. Established heads of household bounce within a year. I think if you are younger, with fewer connections to the outside world, then you are (a) less risk averse (this is biological fact) and (b) have less to lose (existential risk does not affect you the same way as someone with children) and (c) are easier to brainwash because you are more socially isolated (watch any documentary about how cults form).
Can just stop right there. No need to keep brainstorming.
> It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it.