Rendered at 17:17:11 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Cloudflare Workers.
thriving_earthw 20 hours ago [-]
If you want stock trading by congressional representatives (or government officials more broadly) to be banned, I don't think it matters whether they actually beat the market.
The best argument against stock trading is that even the appearance or potential for impropriety of this kind violates the public trust and undermines faith in our governing institutions.
Being an elected official should come with borderline draconian limits on how you are allowed to spend your money.
czhu12 20 hours ago [-]
Is there any risk this just filters out any sensible people from ever wanting to be a politician and selects for the wrong type of person entering those jobs
afavour 20 hours ago [-]
Yes. The reality is (and always has been, really) that we should pay our politicians very well. It would make corruption less appealing and attract a higher level of candidate in the first place. Not to mention open it up to a broader range of candidates.
Unfortunately it’s an enormously unpopular idea.
rileymat2 20 hours ago [-]
There are numerous jobs where corruption would make more than the pay. It has to be about oversight and accountability, not paying so much corruption is not appealing.
maoberlehner 9 hours ago [-]
Is there any source supporting that claim?
I find it equally likely that higher pay would attract more people who’s primary motivation is money, making them even more prone to corruption.
It’s already a problem that politics attracts people who primarily want power. I don’t know if people who primarily want money aren’t even worse (or if there even is a difference).
alyeska2 2 hours ago [-]
I'm reminded of an old Simpsons episode where Homer becomes the union leader at his job and asks what it pays, and he's told "Nothing, unless you're crooked".
It's a joke, but with an element of truth - an honest person is putting in work as a volunteer, but a person willing to take bribes or sell-out the union members for their own personal gain can profit from the same effort. It's a real challenge of misaligned incentives.
As a real-world example, there are countries where police are paid so little that there's a broad expectation that bribes and extortion are a part of their total compensation that brings them up to a living wage (like tips for waiters in the US).
It's at least plausible that a person making $1 million per year would be harder to bribe and feel they had more to lose by taking the risk than a person making $100k.
dd8601fn 3 hours ago [-]
When it comes to political corruption, I don’t think there’s a dependable number you could pay to make these people not want more.
We already have billionaire politicians using their office to run financial scams and extract massive bribes. They’re not doing it because they’re struggling.
Maybe some positions should be paid better, but probably not as a fix for corruption.
disgruntledphd2 6 hours ago [-]
> I find it equally likely that higher pay would attract more people who’s primary motivation is money, making them even more prone to corruption.
I mean, I'd like to run to be a politician at some point. Unfortunately, this would mean taking a paycut and working much longer hours.
Hard to justify it in this scenario (my mortgage can't be paid with votes unfortunately).
xnx 12 hours ago [-]
> attract a higher level of candidate in the first place
There are good arguments for making political position appointments random, like jury duty.
I'm all for paying politicians well and this has nothing to do with that.
The only way to beat the market over the long terms by trading individual stocks is to either devote essentially all of your time to it or to trade on insider information. We have a strong interest in our politicians doing neither of those things.
What makes far more sense is that our politicians be forced to invest their money in broad base index funds (of stocks, bonds, commodities, or other instruments) and that trading be restricted to 4 or so trading windows a year. That still allows them to get market returns.
If we filter out the people for who market returns are not good enough...I'm okay with that? First of all, if they think that, they are probably delusional. They think can out trade Citadel and Ren Tech to get some part of the minuscule amount of alpha out there in the market? On the off chance they are not delusional, then they should probably go into finance as they'll make a greater contribution there than they will in congress. Or they want to inside trade, and we're obviously ok without that.
19 hours ago [-]
lukan 19 hours ago [-]
For someone who is only in it for the money, how much you think would satisfy their ego?
They will always compare themself to the CEO's or company owners they meet with, it would be expansive to match that. Or more concretely, how much money would be enough for Trump, so he does not do deals, that are mainly beneficial to him and his crowd?
skeeter2020 19 hours ago [-]
Why should "politician" be a career? Maybe that's what we should filter for.
carefulfungi 18 hours ago [-]
What are the skills needed to be an effective representative and do those skills improve with time and practice?
c22 17 hours ago [-]
We should select politicians the way we select jurors.
thriving_earthw 17 hours ago [-]
Super interesting idea that has been proposed in the past. Maybe it'll have its moment one day.
What laws will we require our "elected" representatives to NOT know about? Who is the judge who can "throw away" our government members chosen by sortition?
matteoraso 16 hours ago [-]
Most people don't know enough about the political process for this to work, and you run the risk of somebody totally unsuitable ending up as leader.
scrame 16 hours ago [-]
Yeah, imagine if that happened.
akerl_ 20 hours ago [-]
Aren’t the sensible folks the ones buying index funds?
tclancy 20 hours ago [-]
Yes and any large position in anything else by a person on either side of the aisle smells like shit.
hunterpayne 15 hours ago [-]
The way this data is presented and analyzed is pretty weird. Normally, you measure investments by total dollar amounts. This measures each trade equally with outliers excluded (by using median instead of mean). These disclosures cover all trades, not necessarily trades with "insider knowledge". So this methodology is the same I would design to hide a small number of large "insider trades" inside a much larger body of "non-insider" trades. It would be expected for that this second body of trades to be pretty bad (most people's are). And they are excluding the big paydays from insider knowledge and watering down their effects again a larger body of smaller regular trades.
Basically, this report is designed to hide the actual effect of insider trading. It should also be noted that when a campaign ends, any money left over goes to the politician. Finally, it should be noted that the net worth of people in Congress seems to go up on average by surprising degrees (say 10x or more of their base pay). How much comes from each which type of windfall, its hard to say.
bshaughn 20 hours ago [-]
Wouldn't it have the opposite effect ? Maybe I'm jaded but I would say we have very few sensible politicians as is now.
conductr 19 hours ago [-]
I think it’s highlighting that it would just be a false sense that we can define a perfect filter and it could actually backfire and be worse than our current status quo.
I personally don’t like wealthy always being in politics, but I do at least think they are familiar with large budgets and understand some fiscal issues. We have to acknowledge that as you leave the 1%ers, in the US, you’re quickly in a demographic that lives paycheck to paycheck and not just because of their income level. I don’t necessarily want those people controlling our national budgets, or don’t think it would be wise, and I don’t think the temptation to skim/benefit where they can would be eliminated. It might be even more pronounced, as it’s seen as a path to make money more so as the benevolence of public service we all imagine it should be. They might be more likely to give in to overt corruption versus exploiting a loophole or something similar.
It seems odd because we’re spinning further and faster into our end as a nation, or so it feels, so some change may be necessary but I don’t think this really helps. It might just exacerbate the issue.
tclancy 20 hours ago [-]
Uh you think glory hounds with messianic complexes and a need to be loved would quit because of investment restrictions.
everforward 19 hours ago [-]
Sensible people largely invest in index funds or retirement accounts, which this wouldn’t prevent.
Practically every single one of these proposals only restricts your ability to buy and trade a particular stock. You can still trade stocks, you can still have an account manager, you can still tell them you want more exposure to solar, you just can’t tell them you want to buy RandomSolarCo by 4pm Thursday.
barney54 19 hours ago [-]
Even this is too much discretion. Members of Congress should be limited to index funds and no individual stock ownership.
Affric 18 hours ago [-]
No, because you face no risk greater than you would be not being a politician. All that is done currently is incentivising people who wish to be inside traders.
zugi 20 hours ago [-]
Yes and in fact, banning individual stock trades would likely force anyone who already owns individual stocks that have appreciated and wants to run for office to sell them and pay a large capital gains tax bill. That disincentivizes anyone who is financially successful from running for office, unless long ago they decided to only invest in mutual funds.
It seems as this article indicates, the 2012 stock sale reporting requirement has made it hard for members of Congress to trade on insider knowledge. However, the public perception hasn't caught up, leaving to demands for more restrictions.
tekacs 19 hours ago [-]
I feel like we see this in all sorts of disciplines with law – e.g. the massive pile of minimum wage, idle time protection, tipping protection, etc. that NYC now has for delivery drivers.
People don't seem to realize (other than Regulatory Response Fees), the extent to which the city _has_ addressed a lot of the issues with being a delivery driver [1].
A lot of folks therefore still make a bunch of outdated arguments and advocate for things that already exist, or try to _forcibly_ find/portray that things _must_ still be broken, because they argue as if the inputs follow from the conclusion they believe must inevitably always be true (e.g. believing that people 'must' be being screwed over).
Probably also very simply downstream from 'once you've developed an organization to argue for a cause, the cause can't cleanly retire itself'.
In the US, retroactive criminal legislation is largely banned by the Constitution, so it's unlikely existing traders would have to do anything, much less sell all their stock. I could see the law saying all current and future officials must move their investments (and those of immediate family) to a blind trust, but that shouldn't have any tax implications.
zugi 15 hours ago [-]
Sorry, maybe I wasn't clear. My point was that if they have individual stocks and are banned from trading individual stocks, then before entering public office they'd have to either sell them (and pay a big capital gains tax bill), or commit to sitting on them for years until they leave office.
Not necessarily a show-stopper, but one more thing to dissuade some people from running for office.
vmg12 20 hours ago [-]
Being prevented from trading stocks doesn't mean they can't invest in index funds.
thriving_earthw 20 hours ago [-]
I would be concerned about timing the trades of index funds, so I would propose something like you have to do a one-time rebalancing of your portfolio into index funds and it remains locked up for the entire duration of your term.
But they should definitely be able to invest in index funds at the start because you want them to have some skin in the game of the economy that they are in effect managing.
bronco21016 20 hours ago [-]
My org just has a quarterly trading window for company stock. Prevents insiders from timing big events.
Seems like this could be a component. You can trade index funds but only once a quarter.
trollbridge 19 hours ago [-]
Yeah it does, because part of insider trading is simply trading on overall market beta.
ghaff 20 hours ago [-]
Depends on the way the laws are written. Also blind trusts.
forgetfreeman 19 hours ago [-]
I would think this would aggressively filter out exactly the individuals we don't want anywhere near the reigns of power. Public school teachers do what they do for the love of the game because they certainly aren't getting paid well. Same goes for fire and EMS. I see absolutely no reason why the same shouldn't apply to politicians.
cykros 20 hours ago [-]
Plenty of people who work in the financial services industry face FAR more draconian restrictions on what sort of trading is allowed. Between trade limits, and many unable to invest in anything other than (a limited set of) passive mutual funds and ETF's. And we're not talking about portfolio managers and financial planners -- we're talking even entry level people picking up the phone to find out who to transfer you to jobs.
Expecting that persons in Congress be subject to the same limitations is hardly an issue. And if they don't like it, perhaps they should reflect on the fact that prior to their breaking the fiat currency by spending FAR more than we'd ever be able to pay back, you could, you know, actually just save MONEY and not have the value of your labor stolen by monetary debasement.
Give them a little motivation to return us to the sound money the Constitution calls for and who knows, they might even do it.
tipperjones 19 hours ago [-]
You'd think it would make it worse than it already is?
grey-area 20 hours ago [-]
We already have the wrong people applying for these jobs.
ada1981 19 hours ago [-]
No, that’s already happened.
hsuduebc2 20 hours ago [-]
I wouldn't call someone who enters politics with the intention of making a fortune through insider trading sensible. I'd just call them corrupt.
forgetfreeman 19 hours ago [-]
There was a time when I would have been shocked, and I mean absolutely floored, to find out there where enough absolute scumbags on HN willing to advertise the fact by downvoting something as uncontroversial as this.
hsuduebc2 9 hours ago [-]
I kinda am. Since when is saying that corrupt politicians are bad controversial? What's that even supposed to mean? That it's more nUaNcEd than that, or what?
forgetfreeman 4 hours ago [-]
I dunno what to tell you here. In years (decades?) past the FOSS crowd and the academics would have formed Voltron and shouted down all but the most oblique nod to business casual sociopathy.
epolanski 20 hours ago [-]
So you're convinced that there's more risk of filtering sensible people out of politics with such a ban rather than the opposite, meaning having people act out of self interest because of their portfolio or knowledge?
RussianBot9580 20 hours ago [-]
Not really, but draconian laws won't fix the problem either. All insider trading will just happen via proxies. Friends and relatives.
thriving_earthw 20 hours ago [-]
I think you could have restrictions that make it extremely risky for friends and families to trade as proxies. You could have statutes that codify a judicial presumption for the proposition that a friend or family member of a congressperson making a trade anywhere near close in time or that could be plausibly related to the elected official's access to information is guilty, almost a strict liability standard for this kind of thing.
The degree to which this touches extended circles of friends and families does start to implicate reasonable tradeoffs between who would decide to run for office in the first place.
But I think we're just construing the moral standard for elected officials totally wrong. Nobody is making you run for office. You don't need to be doing this, and you are literally in charge of some of the most awesome power, authority, and responsibility human beings on this planet have ever known.
For God's sake, members of the clergy have to wear a uniform and abstain from sex and having families. I'm not saying we should have our elected officials become a priesthood, but I think we can look to other models of human organization and the way groups keep leaders entrusted with awesome responsibility in check to figure out ways to preserve the public trust that elected officials wield.
cucumber3732842 19 hours ago [-]
>I think you could have restrictions that make it extremely risky for friends and families to trade as proxies.
I'm not sure that doesn't just get you the status quo but worse.
So if a politician has a moral compass and gives the machine the bird the machine investigates their families and we all know the laws are gonna be written so that if they wanna find something they will. Of course those who are protected by the machine will still do their thing unfettered.
sensanaty 18 hours ago [-]
That's still insider trading. I work in finance/payments processing and I'm certainly not allowed to tell any one my friends or family which trades to make if I have non-public information about companies, I see no reason why we can't treat politicians to the same exact standards plenty of regular folk already are held to.
etcetcetcetceta 7 hours ago [-]
Only because it can be inferred that you benefitted from sharing that information, you could tell an anonymous individual providing you were not compensated for the tip.
sensanaty 3 hours ago [-]
At least in the Netherlands where I signed my banker's oath, I can't disclose this type of information to anyone, regardless of whether I benefit from it or not. The rough translation of the Dutch rule is something like "unlawful disclosure of inside information", which is separate from trading on the information you possess.
Besides, those anonymous individuals could then be found liable for insider trading themselves, since they quite literally got their information from an insider (me).
etcetcetcetceta 3 hours ago [-]
Ah, I made the classic error of assuming everyone online is american.
Foolish of me given I am European aswell.
epolanski 20 hours ago [-]
That's still insider trading.
marcusverus 19 hours ago [-]
"Draconian law" doesn't mean "an overreaching/unnecessary law" or "a law I don't like", it means "a law backed up by extremely harsh penalties". I'm not advocating for them, but draconian laws would absolutely solve this problem, including trading by proxy. Nobody would risk the death penalty to help a friend or relative trade stocks.
PaulHoule 19 hours ago [-]
People get the death penalty for white collar crimes in China all the time and it never seems to stop them.
mbesto 20 hours ago [-]
My friend, do you think ANY of the current people in congress are sensible people? C'mon...
cyberrock 14 hours ago [-]
I wonder if there's any way to turn this bug into a feature. For example, requiring national-level politicians to put 50% of their net worth into long term investments so they're naturally inclined to make long term decisions.
rogerrogerr 14 hours ago [-]
I’ve thought before that this is solvable by just requiring them to announce their trades thirty seconds ahead of time. Market will do the rest to make sure there’s no alpha left for anyone using insider info.
jameslk 20 hours ago [-]
There is overwhelming bipartisan support for banning public officials from stock trading, such as this recent survey:
> Overwhelming bipartisan majorities favor prohibiting stock-trading in individual companies by Members of Congress (86%, Republicans 87%, Democrats 88%, independents 81%), as well as the President, Vice President, and Supreme Court Justices (87%, Republicans 87%, Democrats 90%, independents 82%) according to an in-depth survey by the Program for Public Consultation at the University of Maryland’s School of Public Policy.
Yet there is barely any movement to do anything about it. A pretty blatant failure of democracy in the US
I think we tend to have a very different perception of Representatives' job requirements than what they do. To them, their job is (a) an obedient voter and speaker for their caucus, (b) a superstar fundraiser for their caucus, and (c) a broker-at-large of power and funds. Probably in reverse order of ambition, as well.
flowerthoughts 11 hours ago [-]
The actual fact probably doesn't matter, but the story does.
The way to a ban is by having the public rally behind the idea. And the way the way to do that is to broadcast an eye catching story. Just saying "ban" again and again is not evoking emotions, so it'll be generally ignored.
thisisauserid 20 hours ago [-]
We need draconian laws to curtail some people's rights?
maerF0x0 18 hours ago [-]
I agree, and I've often pondered what might happen if we, for example, started to tie their earnings over minimum wage to something like the median income? (or a multiple of 20th percentile!) Imagine if politicians knew the only way to get a raise was to make the rest of us richer first?
cmrdporcupine 20 hours ago [-]
Yes part of the problem is the "invisible" part which is more about what policy changes get enacted that wouldn't be if investors weren't part of market? Or what potential regulations -- that might be in the majority's interest -- are not being enacted...
Like, there's legitimate reasons to believe that real estate is as f*cked here in Canada as it is because a large % of members of parliament are either landlords or closely associated with them or at least feel beholden to the property market and realtors as a constituency. Policies which punish housing market inflation are simply inconceivable to them because of their intrinsic biases. Regardless of whether they themselves are "cashing in", or whether they're doing better than the average real estate owner, they still don't represent the general public
Or, put it another way: the foxes are in charge of the hen house.
matteoraso 19 hours ago [-]
>Like, there's legitimate reasons to believe that real estate is as f*cked here in Canada as it is because a large % of members of parliament are either landlords or closely associated with them or at least feel beholden to the property market and realtors as a constituency.
Huh? Housing is a provincial issue, and the provinces usually devolve housing policy-making down to the cities. The federal government only has a very minor role in housing, mostly just in providing mortgages and provincial transfers.
cmrdporcupine 19 hours ago [-]
I don't see how the same argument I just made doesn't apply to members of provincial legislatures? It's the same foxes, regardless of which level of gov't they're sitting in.
Also fed gov't retains control over immigration as well as foreign ownership laws, federal taxation, and, to some degree, monetary policy.
matteoraso 19 hours ago [-]
Except Canadian political culture is famously very collectivist. Individual parliamentarians almost never vote independently of their party. It doesn't matter if you're a landlord if the whip tells you to vote for a YIMBY policy.
>It's the same foxes, regardless of which level of gov't they're sitting in.
I don't understand where this populist resentment for politicians come from. I've talked to a few politicians before (and am seriously considering a run for parliament myself), and they all seem like fine people. I actually think it's noble to dedicate yourself to serving your community, even if it's only for a few years.
allthetime 20 hours ago [-]
uh, but then only people who actually wanted to make a positive impact would do it...
tzs 19 hours ago [-]
I don’t see why that would limit it to people wha want to make a positive impact.
nelox 20 hours ago [-]
[dead]
zug_zug 20 hours ago [-]
Median performance? That's not a correct calculation.
To calculate proper stock returns you need weighted mean. Often in stocks you have a few outliers that give the vast majority of your profit.
I don't know if this is ignorance, but from a methodological standpoint this seems like an attempt to deceive or hide data.
somid3 20 hours ago [-]
True, Im seeing that 10% of the intra day trades were were on companies that changed 5% of value that same day. I uploaded the raw data here if you want to check.
Plus the S&P 500 is not "the market". It's a subset of the total US market that usually performs pretty close to the total US market, but a few percent difference either direction in performance isn't unusual, especially over less than a year.
And I don't think equal weighted S&P 500 is sufficiently motivated.
dodger-dog 19 hours ago [-]
That was my read, and I don't want to bother spending the time to check it. I'm sure they beat the market. Also, I'd want to separate the congress persons who have been in office for say 3 terms or more. I'd also want to correlate stock purchases to the committee that they are on.
glenstein 18 hours ago [-]
Actually if you look at the various research pages, none of them seem to succeed at identifying anything that beats the market. It looks like a big mess if I try to quote a bunch of it, but just check the abstracts for each of the articles. They all conclude basically no effect.
Even ignoring proper returns, corrupt trades would show up as outliers, so the only thing this analysis shows is that there are a lot of normal looking trades.
ricardobeat 20 hours ago [-]
I was puzzled seeing this, after many many reports of government officials having absurd 100-200% returns in their portfolio.
defrost 18 hours ago [-]
Without wading into the political hairball (I'm not a US citizen), you can expect to see manymany reports originating from tabloid presses determined to cast shade.
The many many reports very likely reflect relatively few incidents that involve relatively few officials .. and some of those incidents are very probably framed to make things look far worse and more corrupt than they actually are.
Note: Yes, corruption exists in all governments. Always has, always will - what matters are the mechanisms to iterate over actions and highlight as much actual corruption as possible, and the public prosecution of corruption when it comes to light.
seizethecheese 17 hours ago [-]
Confirmed that if you look at weighted mean, congressmen beat the s&p500. (Since the source link is clearly slop, I think it’s fair game to post a slop rebuttal, otherwise impossible to combat bullshit.)
If you only measure median performance as this is doing, do any group of individuals' stock trades beat the market? I'd expect most of the alpha to come not from the median transaction but from a few well timed buys or sales.
lesuorac 20 hours ago [-]
It’s also not the market. It’s a SNP comparison.
But at the same time, if I buy a bunch of NVDA stock and lobby congress to loosen export rules and fail then I’ll have a bad return but its still not behavior we want.
throooooo 20 hours ago [-]
What is SNP? S&P, as in Standard and Poor's?
jurf 20 hours ago [-]
S ’n’ P, I guess
kennywinker 21 hours ago [-]
From the discussion section:
> It does not show that no member ever trades on what they know: a few well-timed trades can hide inside thousands of ordinary ones, and this test looks at the typical trade, not the best one.
wodenokoto 20 hours ago [-]
But if you look at the well timed transactions and compare that to the market then … the market will beat the market.
somid3 21 hours ago [-]
I remember reading they don't disclose the exact date and hour of the purchase and sale, so intra-day trading or tight timeline trades are impossible to measure, is that correct?
Okay, so the above criticism really only applies to day trading or buying the day of news. I’m guessing that’s very uncommon. If I were a congressman with information I wouldn’t wait until the day of to buy.
sakopov 20 hours ago [-]
If I remember right you can also disclose days, weeks or months after the actual transaction took place and just pay some miniscule fine as a slap on the wrists.
rafram 20 hours ago [-]
You remember wrong, sort of - the law requires the paperwork to be filed within 45 days, so there's no real-time disclosure requirement at all. The fine is very small, though, starting at $200 per violation.
somid3 21 hours ago [-]
I asked Claude:
Does this article take into account intraday trading or trading where the purchase and the sale occurs within 45 days?
And:
"Is there a way someone could have generated a positive revenue even though they reported as negative?"
Conclusion -- their numbers could still allow someone to make positive return even though they report mostly negative alpha
Gosh I love AI for analyzing lousy reports and articles that are inaccurate.
collabs 21 hours ago [-]
Sure, as long as you actually follow through and go to primary sources and do that analysis, I see no problem with using Claude as a starting point. However, please actually go to the sources it gave you and do the analysis yourself. This is way too important for someone to be able to handwave us and say we are wrong.
Tl;Dr please double check with the sources that Claude gave you?
somid3 21 hours ago [-]
I'm downloading the data as we speak :)
somid3 20 hours ago [-]
So it seems of the intra-day trades, 10% of the trades occurred on companies that gained 5% in value that same day? Not sure about this, uploading the data to a Google spreadsheet for everyone who wants to analyze this.
For example Judy Chu seems to have 51% of trades intra day. 571 total trades, 291 were intra day.
somid3 20 hours ago [-]
About 25% of all trades are within the time frame required to report, so its impossible to tell if there was a gain or loss on those trades
somid3 20 hours ago [-]
total 207,000 trades if anyone wants a copy email me somid3 at gmail. I wanna analyze the crap out of this data. Have some free time today
kennywinker 21 hours ago [-]
The article literally says as much, you do have to read it tho. Taking claudeslop as gospel is gonna make you some mistakes.
somid3 21 hours ago [-]
I used it as high-level analysis, I'm downloading the data to do my own analysis. Seems 12% of trades are intra-day... but that's the early data I'm seeing
matteoraso 20 hours ago [-]
Yeah, I've looked at the net worth of various congressmen recently, and most of the wealthy members were wealthy from before politics. Americans complain about their politicians only getting into the career to get rich, but that doesn't seem to be true. In fact, it's kind of shocking how little they get paid, considering they run one of the most powerful countries in the world. This is even more true at the state level.
thriving_earthw 20 hours ago [-]
They should be paid a ton. And in exchange, no stock trading, complete divestiture from any private businesses, and like a 10 year ban on employment in any private sector capacity remotely related to anything they legislated on or worked on while in office, to name a few sensible restrictions.
epolanski 20 hours ago [-]
This.
Many democracies have similar rules that prevent conflict of interests, but compensate you well.
trollbridge 19 hours ago [-]
$175k seems like a pretty decent salary.
Your proposed role of diverstitute from private business would mean nobody with any business sense would run for office, which doesn't seem like a good thing.
BobaFloutist 19 hours ago [-]
It seems pretty good, until you remember that they have to (not legally, but if they want to keep their job) maintain residences in HCOL DC and in their home district, which could also be HCOL. That's pretty hard to do on 175k
etherlink 17 hours ago [-]
[dead]
mchristen 20 hours ago [-]
It's not that shocking when you consider that because these positions pay so little they self select for more wealthy people in general.
seizethecheese 19 hours ago [-]
And for the less wealthy it creates a huge incentive to leave office after a term or two and go into lobbying.
claw-el 20 hours ago [-]
I wonder why the US compensates the judges comparatively well, but not Congress. Should Congress be similarly well compensated like the judiciary so that Congress attracts more talent.
laughing_man 18 hours ago [-]
But they do get rich in office, just not off of stock. It's mostly campaign contributions laundered through things like book sales.
AngryData 18 hours ago [-]
They earn 3x the median wage, how is that shockingly little?
hattar 20 hours ago [-]
> In fact, it's kind of shocking how little they get paid
Yes, it’s almost as if they’re doing this job for some other reason.
TeMPOraL 20 hours ago [-]
Right, but then as others point out, it leads to self-selection: they're also the ones who can already afford to work for reasons other than getting paid.
cm2187 20 hours ago [-]
Not sure the average representative is the right benchmark, that's not the real insiders. The real insiders would be in the upper ranks of congress, with prominent seats in commissions, part of security briefings, and with front row in draft legislations (the average representative first discovers the proposed new law when a 7000 pages final version is dropped on their desk 20 minutes before the vote).
cmrdporcupine 20 hours ago [-]
Sure, or friends of the representatives who just reward said representatives later after they leave congress, etc.
somid3 20 hours ago [-]
If anyone wants to analyze the raw data using R or AI or whatever, you can find it here:
So it seems of the intra-day trades, 10% of the trades occurred on companies that gained 5% in value that same day? Not sure about this, uploading the data to a Google spreadsheet for everyone who wants to analyze this.
I think politicians should be paid according to their performance - how well their constituents are doing. If the McDonald's index shows people are getting relatively poorer, politicians' pay should adjusted accordingly.
vadigepalli 18 hours ago [-]
This is very cool. I built something similar to help bring to light only few hedge fund managers ever beat SP500.
Another nice example of Claude vibe coding put to good use. It's going to be weird to wrap my head around purpose built websites that organize and sort deep dive info being as accessible and interchangeable as spreadsheets.
lindnertim 20 hours ago [-]
Why not make all trades public information?
somid3 20 hours ago [-]
they are, you just have to scrape it or download it
rvz 20 hours ago [-]
Even given that they are public, the trades these congresspeople make have to be disclosed after 30 days.
An obvious edge that can be abused for insider trading in congress.
This is meaningless. If a house member has real inside info, they wouldn't trade as themselves anyway. Get someone else to do it, sort out the kickback later.
FrustratedMonky 20 hours ago [-]
Web site is bit to get through.
So do they beat the market or not?
wasabi991011 18 hours ago [-]
No way to know, because they only check the median
glenstein 20 hours ago [-]
From the abstract:
>Measured from the day a trade became public, the median purchase did −2.4% against the equal-weighted index over six months (90% range −3.9% to +0.1%), and the median stock members sold did −1.7%: what they bought did no better than what they sold. Measured from the members' own trade dates, purchases did −1.5%. No group of purchases (by party, size, account or disclosure delay) did clearly better than the index.
Not what you would have guessed, given that the topic was inspiring enough to make one person ask AI to vibe code a website to present the info. But negative results are results too and deserve to be reported.
Edit: Actually this is more fascinating than I originally thought. All the the abstracts for ALL of the "research" pages are finding no benefit! Everything on the site is carefully worded, included lots of language about "even when it doesn't prove anything" as a mark of transparency. But all the abstracts of all the research find zero advantage from insider stock purchases. And nobody on the report card shows an advantage either. It's still a perfectly legitimate thing for the site to be analyzing but hard not to notice that a site which would seem to be motivated by the possibility of identifying performance advantages is comprehensively not finding any.
FrustratedMonky 3 hours ago [-]
That is pretty counter intuitive.
On one hand, it kind of exonerates the house members, in terms of their corruption.
On other hand, this site seems to want to sell some knowledge, an edge in trading, by following house members. So the site selling info has to acknowledge the info isn't very good.
100111011111 19 hours ago [-]
They can place false bs deliberate losses, they should be banned outright, jesus, there's a think in banking called PEP but in the usa, its somehow okay having trump do what he's doing and Pelosi what she was doing.
The best argument against stock trading is that even the appearance or potential for impropriety of this kind violates the public trust and undermines faith in our governing institutions.
Being an elected official should come with borderline draconian limits on how you are allowed to spend your money.
Unfortunately it’s an enormously unpopular idea.
I find it equally likely that higher pay would attract more people who’s primary motivation is money, making them even more prone to corruption.
It’s already a problem that politics attracts people who primarily want power. I don’t know if people who primarily want money aren’t even worse (or if there even is a difference).
It's a joke, but with an element of truth - an honest person is putting in work as a volunteer, but a person willing to take bribes or sell-out the union members for their own personal gain can profit from the same effort. It's a real challenge of misaligned incentives.
As a real-world example, there are countries where police are paid so little that there's a broad expectation that bribes and extortion are a part of their total compensation that brings them up to a living wage (like tips for waiters in the US).
It's at least plausible that a person making $1 million per year would be harder to bribe and feel they had more to lose by taking the risk than a person making $100k.
We already have billionaire politicians using their office to run financial scams and extract massive bribes. They’re not doing it because they’re struggling.
Maybe some positions should be paid better, but probably not as a fix for corruption.
I mean, I'd like to run to be a politician at some point. Unfortunately, this would mean taking a paycut and working much longer hours.
Hard to justify it in this scenario (my mortgage can't be paid with votes unfortunately).
There are good arguments for making political position appointments random, like jury duty.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sortition
The only way to beat the market over the long terms by trading individual stocks is to either devote essentially all of your time to it or to trade on insider information. We have a strong interest in our politicians doing neither of those things.
What makes far more sense is that our politicians be forced to invest their money in broad base index funds (of stocks, bonds, commodities, or other instruments) and that trading be restricted to 4 or so trading windows a year. That still allows them to get market returns.
If we filter out the people for who market returns are not good enough...I'm okay with that? First of all, if they think that, they are probably delusional. They think can out trade Citadel and Ren Tech to get some part of the minuscule amount of alpha out there in the market? On the off chance they are not delusional, then they should probably go into finance as they'll make a greater contribution there than they will in congress. Or they want to inside trade, and we're obviously ok without that.
They will always compare themself to the CEO's or company owners they meet with, it would be expansive to match that. Or more concretely, how much money would be enough for Trump, so he does not do deals, that are mainly beneficial to him and his crowd?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sortition
Basically, this report is designed to hide the actual effect of insider trading. It should also be noted that when a campaign ends, any money left over goes to the politician. Finally, it should be noted that the net worth of people in Congress seems to go up on average by surprising degrees (say 10x or more of their base pay). How much comes from each which type of windfall, its hard to say.
I personally don’t like wealthy always being in politics, but I do at least think they are familiar with large budgets and understand some fiscal issues. We have to acknowledge that as you leave the 1%ers, in the US, you’re quickly in a demographic that lives paycheck to paycheck and not just because of their income level. I don’t necessarily want those people controlling our national budgets, or don’t think it would be wise, and I don’t think the temptation to skim/benefit where they can would be eliminated. It might be even more pronounced, as it’s seen as a path to make money more so as the benevolence of public service we all imagine it should be. They might be more likely to give in to overt corruption versus exploiting a loophole or something similar.
It seems odd because we’re spinning further and faster into our end as a nation, or so it feels, so some change may be necessary but I don’t think this really helps. It might just exacerbate the issue.
Practically every single one of these proposals only restricts your ability to buy and trade a particular stock. You can still trade stocks, you can still have an account manager, you can still tell them you want more exposure to solar, you just can’t tell them you want to buy RandomSolarCo by 4pm Thursday.
It seems as this article indicates, the 2012 stock sale reporting requirement has made it hard for members of Congress to trade on insider knowledge. However, the public perception hasn't caught up, leaving to demands for more restrictions.
People don't seem to realize (other than Regulatory Response Fees), the extent to which the city _has_ addressed a lot of the issues with being a delivery driver [1].
A lot of folks therefore still make a bunch of outdated arguments and advocate for things that already exist, or try to _forcibly_ find/portray that things _must_ still be broken, because they argue as if the inputs follow from the conclusion they believe must inevitably always be true (e.g. believing that people 'must' be being screwed over).
Probably also very simply downstream from 'once you've developed an organization to argue for a cause, the cause can't cleanly retire itself'.
[1]: https://www.nyc.gov/site/dca/news/073-26/report-finds-nyc-de... (lede: workers’ average hourly earnings, including tips, increased from $10.48 in Q3 2023 to $27.03 in Q2 2026).
Not necessarily a show-stopper, but one more thing to dissuade some people from running for office.
But they should definitely be able to invest in index funds at the start because you want them to have some skin in the game of the economy that they are in effect managing.
Seems like this could be a component. You can trade index funds but only once a quarter.
Expecting that persons in Congress be subject to the same limitations is hardly an issue. And if they don't like it, perhaps they should reflect on the fact that prior to their breaking the fiat currency by spending FAR more than we'd ever be able to pay back, you could, you know, actually just save MONEY and not have the value of your labor stolen by monetary debasement.
Give them a little motivation to return us to the sound money the Constitution calls for and who knows, they might even do it.
The degree to which this touches extended circles of friends and families does start to implicate reasonable tradeoffs between who would decide to run for office in the first place.
But I think we're just construing the moral standard for elected officials totally wrong. Nobody is making you run for office. You don't need to be doing this, and you are literally in charge of some of the most awesome power, authority, and responsibility human beings on this planet have ever known.
For God's sake, members of the clergy have to wear a uniform and abstain from sex and having families. I'm not saying we should have our elected officials become a priesthood, but I think we can look to other models of human organization and the way groups keep leaders entrusted with awesome responsibility in check to figure out ways to preserve the public trust that elected officials wield.
I'm not sure that doesn't just get you the status quo but worse.
So if a politician has a moral compass and gives the machine the bird the machine investigates their families and we all know the laws are gonna be written so that if they wanna find something they will. Of course those who are protected by the machine will still do their thing unfettered.
Besides, those anonymous individuals could then be found liable for insider trading themselves, since they quite literally got their information from an insider (me).
Foolish of me given I am European aswell.
https://drum.lib.umd.edu/items/6dbca567-f940-4897-bde1-02610...
> Overwhelming bipartisan majorities favor prohibiting stock-trading in individual companies by Members of Congress (86%, Republicans 87%, Democrats 88%, independents 81%), as well as the President, Vice President, and Supreme Court Justices (87%, Republicans 87%, Democrats 90%, independents 82%) according to an in-depth survey by the Program for Public Consultation at the University of Maryland’s School of Public Policy.
Yet there is barely any movement to do anything about it. A pretty blatant failure of democracy in the US
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-11-12/congressi...
So it’ll be interesting if they actually do it.
The way to a ban is by having the public rally behind the idea. And the way the way to do that is to broadcast an eye catching story. Just saying "ban" again and again is not evoking emotions, so it'll be generally ignored.
Like, there's legitimate reasons to believe that real estate is as f*cked here in Canada as it is because a large % of members of parliament are either landlords or closely associated with them or at least feel beholden to the property market and realtors as a constituency. Policies which punish housing market inflation are simply inconceivable to them because of their intrinsic biases. Regardless of whether they themselves are "cashing in", or whether they're doing better than the average real estate owner, they still don't represent the general public
Or, put it another way: the foxes are in charge of the hen house.
Huh? Housing is a provincial issue, and the provinces usually devolve housing policy-making down to the cities. The federal government only has a very minor role in housing, mostly just in providing mortgages and provincial transfers.
Also fed gov't retains control over immigration as well as foreign ownership laws, federal taxation, and, to some degree, monetary policy.
>It's the same foxes, regardless of which level of gov't they're sitting in.
I don't understand where this populist resentment for politicians come from. I've talked to a few politicians before (and am seriously considering a run for parliament myself), and they all seem like fine people. I actually think it's noble to dedicate yourself to serving your community, even if it's only for a few years.
To calculate proper stock returns you need weighted mean. Often in stocks you have a few outliers that give the vast majority of your profit.
I don't know if this is ignorance, but from a methodological standpoint this seems like an attempt to deceive or hide data.
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1PD84w61HrL1a6lyAMGCO...
And I don't think equal weighted S&P 500 is sufficiently motivated.
https://arkanumdata.com/research/insider-buys https://arkanumdata.com/research/house-trades https://arkanumdata.com/research/insider-sales https://arkanumdata.com/research/fund-copying
The many many reports very likely reflect relatively few incidents that involve relatively few officials .. and some of those incidents are very probably framed to make things look far worse and more corrupt than they actually are.
Note: Yes, corruption exists in all governments. Always has, always will - what matters are the mechanisms to iterate over actions and highlight as much actual corruption as possible, and the public prosecution of corruption when it comes to light.
https://micjm.com/blog/house-trades-mean-returns/
But at the same time, if I buy a bunch of NVDA stock and lobby congress to loosen export rules and fail then I’ll have a bad return but its still not behavior we want.
> It does not show that no member ever trades on what they know: a few well-timed trades can hide inside thousands of ordinary ones, and this test looks at the typical trade, not the best one.
Does this article take into account intraday trading or trading where the purchase and the sale occurs within 45 days?
And:
"Is there a way someone could have generated a positive revenue even though they reported as negative?"
Conclusion -- their numbers could still allow someone to make positive return even though they report mostly negative alpha
Gosh I love AI for analyzing lousy reports and articles that are inaccurate.
Tl;Dr please double check with the sources that Claude gave you?
ASCII Table below:
+-------------------------------------+---------+----------+----------+-----------+ | Days compared | Count | Close-to | Close-to | Intraday | | | | close | close | high-low | | | | >= 5% | >= 3% | range >=5%| +-------------------------------------+---------+----------+----------+-----------+ | Same-day buy+sell (loose) | 420 | 6.7% | 14.5% | 10.7% | | Same-day buy+sell (strict) | 245 | 5.7% | 13.1% | 8.2% | | Members' other trades, same stocks | 10,957 | 5.2% | 14.5% | 9.0% | | Every trading day, same stocks | 415,259 | 3.4% | 10.7% | 6.8% | +-------------------------------------+---------+----------+----------+-----------+
Many democracies have similar rules that prevent conflict of interests, but compensate you well.
Your proposed role of diverstitute from private business would mean nobody with any business sense would run for office, which doesn't seem like a good thing.
Yes, it’s almost as if they’re doing this job for some other reason.
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1PD84w61HrL1a6lyAMGCO...
I'm having tons of fund.
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1PD84w61HrL1a6lyAMGCO...
https://latticework-x.com/
An obvious edge that can be abused for insider trading in congress.
So do they beat the market or not?
>Measured from the day a trade became public, the median purchase did −2.4% against the equal-weighted index over six months (90% range −3.9% to +0.1%), and the median stock members sold did −1.7%: what they bought did no better than what they sold. Measured from the members' own trade dates, purchases did −1.5%. No group of purchases (by party, size, account or disclosure delay) did clearly better than the index.
Not what you would have guessed, given that the topic was inspiring enough to make one person ask AI to vibe code a website to present the info. But negative results are results too and deserve to be reported.
Edit: Actually this is more fascinating than I originally thought. All the the abstracts for ALL of the "research" pages are finding no benefit! Everything on the site is carefully worded, included lots of language about "even when it doesn't prove anything" as a mark of transparency. But all the abstracts of all the research find zero advantage from insider stock purchases. And nobody on the report card shows an advantage either. It's still a perfectly legitimate thing for the site to be analyzing but hard not to notice that a site which would seem to be motivated by the possibility of identifying performance advantages is comprehensively not finding any.
On one hand, it kind of exonerates the house members, in terms of their corruption.
On other hand, this site seems to want to sell some knowledge, an edge in trading, by following house members. So the site selling info has to acknowledge the info isn't very good.