Rendered at 16:39:48 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Cloudflare Workers.
breakyerself 22 hours ago [-]
Any time this stuff comes up it's important to understand that this el Nino is occuring in the context of a global climate that is warmer than any time in the last 125,000 years. The risks inherent to weather and climate are growing all the time.
stingraycharles 16 hours ago [-]
I’m here in the Philippines and they’re expecting temperatures up to 52 degrees Celsius, which is absolutely insane considering the humidity. Highest temperature so far was 51 degrees during El Niño 2018.
CalRobert 2 hours ago [-]
52C at high humidity would basically kill anyone without air conditioning right? Even healthy people die at wet bulb temps over 35C.
The first chapter of Ministry for the Future explores this idea.
sampullman 10 hours ago [-]
Do you mean 42? That's the highest ever recorded temperature in the Philippines as far as I know.
I live in a similar climate and I'm pretty sure if it hit 52 millions of people would die and a bunch of equipment would fail.
stingraycharles 5 hours ago [-]
Just checked, and you’re right, apparently it’s “heat index” which is adjusted for human perception.
51 was apparently the highest over here before (Cebu) which was at most 37 degrees in actual temperature.
sampullman 5 hours ago [-]
Yeah that makes sense, the perceived humidity here in Taiwan gets up there occasionally.
If the sun's not direct you can manage a few hours without for trouble but I wouldn't want to spend a night without AC.
5 hours ago [-]
austin-cheney 3 hours ago [-]
I have lived in Kuwait for a couple years. It’s record temp is 54, which is pretty hot.
fossilwater 6 hours ago [-]
That sounds like the "human perceived" temperature rather than the temperature seen by thermometers
mrheosuper 13 hours ago [-]
Is that air temperature, how can someone live like that? we sometime reach 40*C and it's really, really bad.
tavavex 11 hours ago [-]
If the temperature lasts for any prolonged amount of time, they can't. Especially not with high humidity, which almost fully prevents the body's heat exchange process and starts pushing your internal temperature. Existing under those conditions is a constant race against the clock where you run from one temperature-controlled place to another, as much less than an hour of exposure to these conditions will lead to extreme strain, followed by heat stroke and death.
cman1444 10 hours ago [-]
The biggest issues occur when nighttime temperatures don't drop low enough, so the body doesn't have time to recover.
10 hours ago [-]
shoobiedoo 14 hours ago [-]
I remember stepping foot into the Manila airport for the first time around ten years ago and my skin just instantly felt sticky from humidity. I'd never felt that before. 52 degrees with high humidity is absolutely insane... stay safe.
brazzy 2 hours ago [-]
52 with high humidity would lead to mass deaths within an hour. The actual temperature was much lower, it felt like 52 due to the high humidity.
criddell 18 hours ago [-]
Is it important? The globe is warming and it’s the new normal. Explaining it one more time isn’t going to make a difference.
Those of us who want to see CO2 reductions need to find solutions that don’t lead to inflation in the short term. It’s probably going to be a technological rather than policy solution.
jazzyjackson 13 minutes ago [-]
Check out “climate: a new story” by Charles Eisenstein. CO2 is a factor but total biomass on earth acts as a buffer to change. We might not convince the world to capture its carbon, but protecting and restoring ecosystems (the existence of which affects weather patterns through all manner of feedback loops!) is more politically viable and relatable to the layperson.
djleni 15 hours ago [-]
There are technological solutions which are also competitive in the market which are actively being fought by politicians the world over.
How do you resolve that without involving policy?
cowlevel 8 hours ago [-]
Solar is the cheapest form of energy right now by an order of magnitude, even accounting for batteries and they still won't use it, and in fact the president even banned it citing national security.
somedude895 4 hours ago [-]
> they still won't use it
Who's "they"?
Also, Trump banned solar?
noosphr 17 hours ago [-]
The link between El Nino and extreme weather is breaking down. The last El Nino caused an extremely wet summer in Australia despite a century of data pointing in the opposite direction.
The current one seems to be doing the same as the old one.
Climate is filled with non linearities and drawing straight lines from the past is a fools errant.
Least we forget the Sahara only turned into a desert when it got less sunshine.
jibalt 17 hours ago [-]
> The link between El Nino and extreme weather is breaking down.
Climate scientists disagree.
> The last El Nino caused an extremely wet summer in Australia despite a century of data pointing in the opposite direction.
No, that occurrence is not inconsistent with the data.
> Climate is filled with non linearities and drawing straight lines from the past is a fools errant.
The word is "errand" and this is absurd ... climate is an average over weather, we can plot a trend line, and that line has an upward slope.
etcetcetcetceta 3 hours ago [-]
"fools errant" describes me and my friends at college.
ern 15 hours ago [-]
I read that weak El-Ninos cause worse droughts in Australia than weaker ones. We need a southern and eastern hemisphere equivalent of this video.
jibalt 14 hours ago [-]
> Climate over the last billion years has been stable an nothing has happened.
Least honest or intelligent and most refuted denier talking point ever.
No, I replied to my own comment, intentionally ... it was too late to edit it.
Now, we're off topic so I won't further discuss where comments get posted.
DiggyJohnson 9 minutes ago [-]
That doesn't make sense to do to anyone other than you btw
noosphr 14 hours ago [-]
The direction of the trend line depends entirely where you start it from.
20,000 years was the peak of the last ice age. Any trend line starting that sooner than that will by definition be increasing. Largely because NYC isn't under 1 mile of glaciers.
When we do in the near future is what when you'll start to give a shit?
bamboozled 12 hours ago [-]
The issue is science will claim something like El Niño = really bad droughts, then somewhere like Australia has a lot of unseasonable rain. It’s not that the science is completely wrong but it destroys the trust. I can’t tell you how many people walk around Australia lately laughing about how incorrect the predictions have been.
>No, that occurrence is not inconsistent with the data.
It is.
>climate is an average over weather, we can plot a trend line, and that line has an upward slope.
Climate over the last billion years has been stable an nothing has happened.
Loquebantur 19 hours ago [-]
The important part to understand here is the childish reaction by major parts of the US populace to the outsize responsibility their country has for the catastrophic development of the global climate.
Instead of acknowledging the scientific facts and the ethical implications thereof, they engage in "catch me if you can"-tactics.
They let themselves be willfully utilized as a shield of ignorance against the financial restitution they owe. Not to speak of the implied loss of influence in the world economy after fossil fuels are phased out.
rustcleaner 18 hours ago [-]
It's because carbon reduction has not been disconnected from material impoverishment. We need more stuff moving; we need more housing, we need more transport, we need more food, we need more energy, we need more children. Carbon reduction's story is one of denying/reducing these things in the name of saving planet earth. The answer needs to be doing both: reducing carbon and making more houses and food and energy and babies. Nobody really wants to be DINK pod-people who have little optionality in life activities, and that's what climate change warriors are selling them.
arijun 7 hours ago [-]
> It's because carbon reduction has not been disconnected from material impoverishment
I don’t think that can be the only reason. For over a decade PV has been cheaper than coal^1, but many of the people opposed to reducing climate change have remained staunch supporters of the coal industry.
^1 Yes, some caveats apply, but as PV/renewables continue to fall in price, fewer and fewer do.
DiggyJohnson 2 minutes ago [-]
I think the amount of people that hold this viewpoint is massively exaggerated and it's essentially the individuals in the coal industry that don't want to lose their livelihoods.
omgwtfbyobbq 14 hours ago [-]
My personal experience has been the opposite, and for the most part energy efficiency, renewables, and so on, usually, but not always, perform better than fossil fuels.
The reason why comes down to exergy. In most cases, we can extract more useful work from a kwh of electricity than a kwh of fossil fuels. And people can usually get more food, more useful energy, more transport, and if they want more kids, in a renewables based economy.
rightnutwingjob 52 minutes ago [-]
> And people can usually get more food, more useful energy, more transport, and if they want more kids, in a renewables based economy.
This would be true, if only it weren’t for the reality that everywhere renewables have penetrated the market to an extent worth talking about electricity has gotten much more expensive and significant deindustrialisation has occurred, as well as the loss of many small businesses that can no longer survive due to that deindustrialisation and / or those much higher electricity costs.
triceratops 48 minutes ago [-]
You're mixing up cause and effect. Renewables penetrated high-electricity-cost markets first because they used to be expensive to install but cheap to operate, making them a good investment.
"Deindustrialization" has little to do with electricity costs. If you're serious please tell us the split between labor and electricity costs for an average car factory in the US, Europe, Japan, and China.
anon7000 9 hours ago [-]
Yeah if you think about solar + battery for long enough, you start to wonder why we’d ever rely on an energy source that requires complex global supply chains and other countries which can disrupt everyone’s lives in a second. And that’s on top of building the actual infrastructure and power plants. So much effort spent on finding and extracting oil, just to burn it.
Or you could get battery + solar and it’ll basically just work for a couple decades and then become recyclable. There’s not even a land problem; it would take less land than we currently use for the corn ethanol mixed into gas.
cowlevel 8 hours ago [-]
We rely on it because the people in those supply chains are incentivized to force them to continue.
rightnutwingjob 50 minutes ago [-]
There’s still no solar / wind / battery solution for diesel.
criddell 12 minutes ago [-]
The US uses something like 7 billion barrels of oil per year and only about a billion of those are for diesel. Tackle diesel later or maybe not at all. Don't let the search for a perfect solution make you miss others that are maybe good enough.
Timon3 6 hours ago [-]
> It's because carbon reduction has not been disconnected from material impoverishment.
IMO this inverts the real chain of causality: it's because carbon reduction has been connected to material impoverishment.
There's endless propaganda blaring how only endless growth can give us prosperity. If you even think about advocating for decreased energy usage, you want to kill poor people and China to win (I've had both of these thrown at me on HN).
We have a multi-trillion industry who has been pouring billions into psychological manipulation. IMO evaluating statements like the quote in this light makes a whole lot of things make sense.
lickonographic 5 hours ago [-]
Spot on. The discourse that fossil fuels are necessary for wealth is propagated by those whose wealth is built on fossil fuels. It is entirely possible to have an even more prosperous society if all the energy sources isn't tied to the profits of the "dig up and pump fuel" concerns.
rightnutwingjob 47 minutes ago [-]
Aluminium and steel production are very energy intensive.
So if you believe we can do without those, sure.
But we can’t.
Concrete is carbon emissions intensive, if you believe we can do without it, sure.
But we can’t.
Timon3 40 minutes ago [-]
Nobody said we should stop producing aluminium and steel.
Nobody said we should stop producing concrete.
dot42 9 hours ago [-]
Saving humanity, not planet earth. Planet earth will be fine when humanity is gone.
Timon3 6 hours ago [-]
I'm always puzzled by this inevitable response. By what measure will earth be fine without us?
pvaldes 6 hours ago [-]
Life in the planet has recovered perfectly from five mass extinctions without our help. Each one of those killed from 75 to 90% of the species alive.
Timon3 6 hours ago [-]
Why is the only relevant measure "is there any life left"?
amiga386 4 hours ago [-]
Because that's what we mean by "Planet Earth will be fine". Earth will continue to hold the trait of being hospitable for life, in a way that we believe all the other planets in our solar system are not. Its distance from the sun, its size, density, atmosphere, water, axial tilt, magnetic field, etc. all very fine qualities in a planet for making life (as we know it) possible.
Earth was about 800 million years old when the first signs of life appeared, and it was 3 billion years old before multicellular life appeared. It took another billion years before things like animals and plants appeared (the Cambrian explosion), and since then there's only been like 500 million years of history.
Most mass extinctions have happened in the past 500 million years and have killed off huge swathes of life on the planet, but new lifeforms have come back, on a much shorter timescale than 4 billion years, because it hasn't had to start from scratch. That's what we mean by "fine", and why it would be a problem if all life (even the single celled life) were eradicated.
Timon3 4 hours ago [-]
> Because that's what we mean by "Planet Earth will be fine".
I seriously doubt the majority of humans agrees that "planet earth will be fine" means "planet earth still has any life left", so that doesn't explain why this is the correct yardstick.
PopAlongKid 1 hours ago [-]
>By what measure will earth be fine without us?
You asked, and got a reasonable answer, which you rejected.
>that doesn't explain why this is the correct yardstick.
Since you seem to have a notion of the "correct yardstick", please share in what ways Planet Earth will not be fine without humans (i.e. your candidates for the correct yardstick).
edit: never mind, I posted this before seeing all your other comments.
pvaldes 2 hours ago [-]
This important theme deserves more than losing your time Sealioning here.
defrost 6 hours ago [-]
The planet has been here for 4 billion odd years and will continue to be here for billions more - this despite the extinction of dinosaurs after a massive meteorite strike, being splatted and damn near cleaved in half by a moon sized chunk .. that created the moon we have, existing for a long period of time with an atmosphere toxic to life as we know it today, and a good while with an essentially molten surface.
This third rock from the sun will happily just keep orbiting on, with or without us, regardless of how much we fart old carbon into the atmosphere.
Timon3 6 hours ago [-]
Do you really not understand that people do not mean "the planet earth" when they refer to "the earth" in this context?
That's what I don't understand. Are you willfully misinterpreting this statement, or do you really not understand?
gilleain 5 hours ago [-]
So without attacking you, I would agree with the other replies in this thread - there is some confusion, generally speaking, when people talk about "destroying the planet" or "destroying life on Earth".
Past changes in climate comparable to current global warming did indeed cause global mass extinctions; the most severe was the Permian-Triassic extinction (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permian%E2%80%93Triassic_extin...). However, life did recover ... it just took millions of years to do so.
I disagree, therefore that it is 'useless pedantry' to distinguish between the ecological damage in the short-term that will definitely affect humans, and the long-term where the biosphere _should_ eventually recover. If anything, the large amount of time relative to human-scale should make it more alarming, not less.
Timon3 4 hours ago [-]
I doubt anyone is seriously confused. There is no objective threshold for "the earth is destroyed", and the majority of people do not use the phrase to mean "the earth has become inhospitable to all life", so insisting that someone is wrong because their use doesn't align with your preferred use is useless pedantry.
gilleain 3 hours ago [-]
I was not clear, my apologies : I am not saying that "people are confused" in the sense that they literally believe the Earth will cease to exist. I mean "these concepts are confused" - in the sense of 'mixed together'.
To put it another way, I think that there is benefit in de-fusing the ideas of destruction of the Earth and harm to the environment (habitat loss, extinction, etc). I do not particularly care about who "insisted you were wrong", that's up to you.
In any case, skimming through your recent comments, notice a bit of a pattern were our discussions get very argumentative. I wish you all the best, and please forgive me but I encourage you not to think of discussions online as arguments that you have to "win". Do as you wish, but I used to do this, and found it stressful and unhelpful in the long run.
Timon3 3 hours ago [-]
I'll get to the topic, but first let me say that I appreciate your advice :) I know what you mean regarding "think[ing] of discussions online as arguments that you have to 'win'", but that's genuinely not what I'm trying to do. For example:
> To put it another way, I think that there is benefit in de-fusing the ideas of destruction of the Earth and harm to the environment (habitat loss, extinction, etc).
I'd love to hear more about what benefit you see in de-fusing these ideas. The reason I even wrote my initial comment is that I see this brought up almost every time anyone mentions "destroying the earth", but I can't remember ever seeing anything productive grow out of this de-fusing. This makes intuitive sense to me: this response does not address the meaning of a message, only the form, which diverts the discussion from the actual topic.
So I'm trying to figure out what I'm missing. What is the benefit of bringing this up almost every time? Unfortunately defrost has been more interested in trolling than answering, so I still don't know. But I'd genuinely love to hear more about your thought process, because I really want to understand your position!
defrost 2 hours ago [-]
> Unfortunately defrost has been more interested in trolling than answering
Stop the slander, re-evaluate your priors, reread your own comments - you were so keen to just keep attacking you missed your chance with me .. maybe later.
Timon3 2 hours ago [-]
I literally wrote one comment to you before you started trolling - I'm not interested in another chance.
defrost 6 hours ago [-]
All my people have a fair grasp of what "the planet earth" means.
Collectively we have a fair to bleeding edge grasp of seismology, magnetotellurics, radiometrics, Gravimetry, tidal modelling, geological time, geological strata, etc.
Are you wilfully misinterpreting these things, or do you really not understand?
Timon3 6 hours ago [-]
What the hell are you talking about, who are "your people"? I can't remotely understand what you're trying to convey.
I didn't ask the question for fun. You seem to be deliberately misinterpreting the statement by rustcleaner. Why? Why not keep to the HN guidelines, and actually respond to their point? As a reminder:
> Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith.
defrost 6 hours ago [-]
> , who are "your people"?
People that study the planet, as opposed to the biosphere.
Timon3 6 hours ago [-]
So you really are just willfully misinterpreting the initial statement, since you're well aware that GP was talking about something else.
Could you maybe not do that? It's not funny or insightful, it just sucks the air out of discussions.
defrost 5 hours ago [-]
You appear to be the one wilfully confusing "a house" with "it's occupants".
Could you maybe not do that? It's not funny or insightful, it just sucks the air out of discussions.
Timon3 5 hours ago [-]
> You appear to be the one wilfully confusing "a house" with "it's occupants".
This is exactly the kind of useless pedantry I'm talking about! It's a completely normal way of speaking, which native english speakers should have encountered countless times: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metonymy
You might not like seeing this figure of speech, but can't you just pull yourself together and not post the same useless "correction" for the millionth time?
defrost 5 hours ago [-]
And can't you just pull yourself together and not post the same useless "correction" for the millionth time?
For a great many people, what you call "useless pedantry" is an important distinction - in the history of planet earth a number of lifeforms have come and gone.
Should humans alter the insulation factor to such a degree than they disrupt the very biosphere that supports them, that's bad for humans.
As far as planet earth goes, it's another wave of life crashing, with others to follow.
Timon3 5 hours ago [-]
> For a great many people, what you call "useless pedantry" is an important distinction - in the history of planet earth a number of lifeforms have come and gone.
"The planet will not literally blow up" is not an important distinction for anyone.
But I've already wasted far too much time with your poor trolling attempts, please do your "I am very smart" schtick somewhere else.
defrost 5 hours ago [-]
You know, from my PoV, as someone who cares a great deal about AGW and planetary systems it's very much yourself that appears to be a troll here.
You asked a question, I answered in good faith, and you've done little other than sling bile since.
it's about something that may very well help a human centric biosphere .. but, you know, it came from people that make a distinction between planetary studies and biosphere studies in order to have a better understanding.
Timon3 5 hours ago [-]
You wrote one response in good faith, to which I responded in good faith. Since then, all your replies have been mocking and trolling: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50516056
wickedsight 8 hours ago [-]
Especially on the macro scale, this will just be another mass extinction event.
Loquebantur 18 hours ago [-]
The idea of "unbounded capitalism", leading to incessant growth, while painting reductions as "impoverishment", is a capital error.
Reality doesn't allow for any such thing and wishing for it doesn't make it so.
Consequently, ignoring that reality will see you running into a wall head-on. With wildly devastating consequences: El Niño is just one immediate symptom, look at the AMOC. It collapsing will see about 70% or more of Earth's population wiped out. Along with the corresponding capacity for crop growth.
What you need to do is actually preventing foreseeable calamities, not complaining about people pointing you at them.
hax0ron3 17 hours ago [-]
rustcleaner didn't say that his or her suggested solution is capitalism, though it might be.
People in communism, or nearly any other socioeconomic system, also want more housing, transport, food, energy, and children.
Reality includes public opinion, which even authoritarian systems have to account for to some extent. So even if the reality is that climate change will be so devastating that it needs to be addressed by any means necessary (I don't know if that is the reality, but let's say for the sake of argument that it is), that necessity has to be sold to people somehow.
And it's difficult to convince people to accept impoverishment if the truly major negative consequences of not acting on climate change are ones that will not happen for decades, as seems to be the case at least in temperate regions. I know very little about AMOC, but it seems the science about AMOC collapse timelines is not settled enough to convince the average person that something must be done immediately.
To get public buy-in in such a situation, it may be more advantageous to figure out how to be able to sell the necessary changes in a way that is not accompanied by impoverishment. That or ignore public buy-in, but then one still has to figure out how to do that. Voters punish economic decline. And I doubt that there is a realistic path to replacing Western democracy with an authoritarian system that has climate change as a top priority, at least in the near future.
wickedsight 8 hours ago [-]
> that necessity has to be sold to people somehow
> consequences of not acting [...] are ones that will not happen for decades
Are you aware of the movie "Don't look up"? Because if not, it might be worth a watch before reading your own comment again. If so, I really wonder what your interpretation of the movie was, since, to me, your comment reads pretty much exactly like how that movie plays out.
Loquebantur 16 hours ago [-]
People "wanting" whatever doesn't mean, they could get it.
Note how absurd the framing here is: "impoverishment" of whom and meaning what? US Americans, among the richest in the world, "falling" to the average? Who is supposed to pity them exactly?
Your idea of "consequences not happening for decades": WTF? So, so long as its not you who bears the downsides, you don't care? How sympathetic.
"Public buy in" is a chimera. You propose, they would buy into anything they're being told, so long as it sounds attractive to them. What's that supposed to mean?
Either, the public believes anything they're being told anyway, or they have to actually grow up and learn to know the truth themselves. It's not about whatever nonsense "political system", it's about epistemology.
As for the AMOC timeline: you could use your own rational mind to figure that out, but you prefer for others to tell you. Unless they tell you what you don't want to hear? Seriously?
samudrijan 15 hours ago [-]
Impoverishment is the new climate denialism. It’s BS.
233mhz 8 hours ago [-]
How does more of everything all the time work on a finite planet with finute resources?
We already produce too much of virtually everything, and that's the whole problem.
rightnutwingjob 41 minutes ago [-]
We should make less housing?
Fricken 16 hours ago [-]
"A society grows great when old men plant trees whose shade they know they shall never sit in"
-Greek proverb you've probably heard before
shrubby 12 hours ago [-]
Ehm, compare this with the likes of Trump and Putin...
Who are making their societies great again, I hear!
CalRobert 2 hours ago [-]
Ironically, more housing near jobs, amenities, and schools would likely reduce carbon emissions because you wouldn't have to go so far to get to everything.
I'm not sure we "need" more people driving a 2.5 ton studio apartment 40 miles to work each way through the desert.
samudrijan 15 hours ago [-]
What a load of baloney. Keep it in the ground. Build interconnect, solar, wind and batteries. Regulate for generation efficiency, better mpg, build out charging infra and public transpo. Eliminate subsidies for beef, O&G.
It’s a lie that decarbonization is going to result in material impoverishment. “Oh my things!!”
rightnutwingjob 32 minutes ago [-]
You’re basically describing Australia.
It hasn’t worked.
Unless you consider an alarm rising in families living in tents ”working,” but you’d be the only one.
We can have expensive “renewables” (they’re not) if, as Jimmy Carr says, “you don’t give a fuck about poor people.”
triceratops 16 minutes ago [-]
You seem to lying all up and down this thread. Australia has so much cheap electricity they give it away for free for some hours of the day. Electricity's got nothing to do with Australia not building enough houses.
I don't know what you're getting out of so much lying.
Jaygles 13 hours ago [-]
| Carbon reduction's story is one of denying/reducing these things in the name of saving planet earth
saving our species
The earth will do fine, and probably better, once we extinct ourselves
DeluluDon 15 hours ago [-]
You're right, we're SINKs instead. Nobody wants to cohabitate with each other or agree with each other and think it's cute and funny to poke fun at each other.
jibalt 17 hours ago [-]
Imagine that ... people warring against an existential threat to human civilization.
d4mi3n 17 hours ago [-]
I think GP statements were more a commentary of human nature. We have these problems because carbon is tied to things people need (e.g. housing, electricity) and to current lifestyles. Add to this that we are terrible at internalizing long term risks as a species and you see what you see.
jibalt 15 hours ago [-]
My response was only regarding the phrase "climate change warriors".
Loquebantur 16 hours ago [-]
You parrot a common nonsense-trope about "human nature" being an explanation here, which is intentionally designed to derail arguments about the topic.
Humans aren't mindless animals, helplessly falling prey to their basic instincts. Claiming as much is an utter absurdity, that should become obvious when observing how selectively that deflection is being used.
"Lifestyle", convenience and "just not getting the long term aspects", those are simply lies. People know perfectly well.
The problem is, they've been taught it was OK for them to act like children, shirking responsibility. They're being covered for by comments like yours.
bpavuk 16 hours ago [-]
> Humans aren't mindless animals, helplessly falling prey to their basic instincts.
there are entire subcultures built on exposing the very "basic instincts" that a considerable majority of us humans fall for. these subcultures are called "religions." all of them attempt to control these "instincts" through concepts such as a "deadly sin".
some things pretty much are the human nature. we make miracles not out of desire for utopia but when we are under a gun. and this particular one is pretty big. extinction-level, I'd say.
lazide 16 hours ago [-]
Nah, you’re just being really dumb in your approach.
They’re ignoring it because they can, and fuck you.
Trying to convince them is pointless because it isn’t about that, and never was.
All you’re doing is wasting your time and showing even more people that their approach “works”.
Hint: scolding the highshool bully about the short term stupidity and bad ethics about their bullying also doesn’t do anything.
lotsofpulp 18 hours ago [-]
>that's what climate change warriors are selling them.
Interesting way to frame the constraints of reality.
dd8601fn 18 hours ago [-]
Maybe I misunderstood, but I think they’re saying that the constraints of reality include, “If their answer requires lesser production, movement, and quality of life, then it never was a thoughtful answer.”
It’s not far from what I’ve always thought. We simply will not solve these problems with broad self-denial. It’s an absurd notion, even if the monastic sheen of it sounds nice.
bko 19 hours ago [-]
US has reduced their global carbon emissions over the last 20 years. We were a peak of 55% of global emissions to less than 13% today, and continue to drop (we were 23% in 2000).
Even when adjusting for trade, it is down considerably over the last 20 years. Mainly due to dematerialization, basically a free market economy doing more with less (e.g. efficient packaging uses less materials and is cheaper).
US and the Western world can continue reducing carbon emissions and it won't make a bit of difference.
Try spending 5 minutes on google before you spout uniformed opinions
The current administration and withdrawn from the Paris agreement, UNFCCC, and IPCC.
Things might have improved from 20 years ago but the more recent governmental trend is not positive.
bko 3 hours ago [-]
Enough with this performative nonsense. No single major nation is on track with 1.5 celcius warming limit of the Paris Agreement
dolmen 8 hours ago [-]
US global CO2 is back growing since 2025 because of raising coal use (as replacement for gas whose price follows oil).
defrost 17 hours ago [-]
> Try spending 5 minutes on google before you spout uniformed opinions
See HN guidelines, specifically in respect to polite discourse, and perhaps steelman their claim.
By "outsize responsibility" they likely refer to the fact that still today the US as a country has been the source of the largest per country contribution to AGW gases (burnt fossil fuels).
They might also refer to 1970s US capitalists (eg: Koch brothers) doubling down hard on climate denial after the papers of 1967 and actively funding think tanks to push civic development towards roads, away from public transport, and make bigger cars sexy.
To this day the cumulative total of fossil gases uplifted by the USofA still exceeds that of China - despite the smaller population of the USofA.
Noaidi 18 hours ago [-]
This statistic completely ignores the fact that the US externalizes its' CO2 emissions by externalizing by sending our manufacturing to other countries.
How much of China's CO2 is a result of the products Americans buy that were manufactured in China?
If we look at CO2 as a result of consumption it would tell a truer story.
rootusrootus 16 hours ago [-]
> How much of China's CO2 is a result of the products Americans buy that were manufactured in China?
Still their emissions. They could choose not to subsidize their industry in pursuit of being manufacturer for the whole world. They do not get to dodge accountability by blaming it on their customers.
fl4regun 3 hours ago [-]
I don't think you can make this claim and give zero responsibility to the consumers, constantly buying stupid low quality non-recyclable BS that they don't really need.
belorn 17 hours ago [-]
The general solution to a global market where countries chooses to have different industry regulations is to impose tariffs to compensate for the real cost of production so that external producers has the same conditions as internal ones.
On the flip side, we should not take away agency from those who choose to favor increased export industry over increased emissions. That is an active choice. Same if they allow poor employment safety or child labor. The importer of goods has some moral responsibility to buy from someone else (even if its more expensive), but the absolute majority of responsibility is on the country that exports. Emission numbers can't be white washed by claiming that it goes to exports, as if being paid to do it means less responsibility (a very strange notion to begin with).
hollerith 17 hours ago [-]
Is that really true?
There are manufacturing processes that use a lot of energy, and the US does a lot of that (maybe more than China) because it has low energy costs.
rdtsc 12 hours ago [-]
> How much of China's CO2 is a result of the products Americans buy that were manufactured in China?
This paints the Chinese as some used puppets of the capitalist West. They would rather hug trees and live on sustainable organic farms but the evil capitalists came and forced them to burn coal and make cheap plastic toys for them. This is removes their agency (individual or government, either way) and I don’t think it’s a fair characterization.
Loquebantur 18 hours ago [-]
You conflate wildly different metrics to paint a simply false overall picture.
The state of the climate is due to the accumulation of CO2 in Earth's atmosphere. You pretend, those past emissions didn't happen. Also, global emissions expanded dramatically over the last 25 years.
The U.S. share of global annual CO2 emissions "peaked" at roughly 55% in 1918 during the height of early American industrialization. Obviously, that's an absurd comparison to mention here. What matters is the overall contribution in actual metric tons.
U.S. emissions are not currently dropping without interruption. After falling roughly 18% to 20% from their 2005 - 2007 peak, U.S. emissions rebounded in 2025, increasing by 2.4% to 3.2% due to colder winter weather, rising electricity demand from data centers, and a 13% jump in coal-fired power generation.
The claim that emissions fell mainly due to "dematerialization" and free-market packaging efficiency is largely inaccurate. While economic efficiency played a supporting role, energy sector transitions were the dominant driver. The reductions were driven primarily by replacing coal with natural gas and renewables in the power sector.
And that's all completely ignoring the systemic influence the US has had and still has.
dolmen 8 hours ago [-]
Gaming with statistics by discussing only US global share instead of absolute numbers to dilute individual responsibility.
0xDEAFBEAD 3 hours ago [-]
Why the focus on the contribution of the US in particular? Why focus specifically on negative contributions, and not mention e.g. Elon Musk's role in popularizing electric cars? Many of the scientists who studied and popularized concern for global warming were also American.
I don't think Loquebantur had any sort of constructive purpose in starting their subthread. I think they are pushing an ideological agenda.
0xDEAFBEAD 3 hours ago [-]
>The U.S. share of global annual CO2 emissions "peaked" at roughly 55% in 1918
Was global warming established as a serious risk in 1918?
You've got a specific set of ideological commitments and conclusions, and instead of arguing for them, you leapt directly into psychoanalyzing why people don't already agree with you. It's very annoying.
willmadden 17 hours ago [-]
Also, China's coal consumption is now larger than... the entire rest of the world's.
These people are not arguing in good faith.
xedrac 17 hours ago [-]
It isn't really in "good faith" to retort something the parent didn't say. Try disputing something that was actually claimed.
defrost 17 hours ago [-]
And yet despite that and having a much larger population the cumulative total CO2 uplift of China is still less than that of the US.
It'd better to avoid country V country pissing contests and focus on global efforts. In a real sense the cost of going solar, wind, renewable powered is Chinese emissions .. for now.
jibalt 17 hours ago [-]
Project much?
cmrdporcupine 19 hours ago [-]
It's gotten bad all over the western world. Here in Canada, just mentioning climate change and policies to restrict CO2 emissions puts you in the political doghouse and gets you crucified on social media. It's just apparently not a concern now. Carney has eviscerated all regulation, and enabling exponential growth of the oil export sector is now a national emergency justified by tariffs, nationalism, national unity etc. etc.
Sorry, great grand-children. Pipelines gotta pump.
ianjbutler 18 hours ago [-]
> in the political doghouse and gets you crucified on social media
This is arguably the correct thing, even if you believe the situation is urgent, if you also believe that other things are more urgent. Suppose you think that fixing declining education or economies is absolutely prerequisite, and that until people are smarter or more comfortable or both, even discussing the climate too often weakens your chances of building effective coalitions.
Personally, I go back and forth when I weigh this sort of thing, I'm really not sure. We probably need to at least consider that this is a consistent/coherent perspective. Of course, it's not a invitation to make things worse as fast as possible with drill-baby-drill.. but an acknowledgement that there are many other ways to make things worse, such as pissing people off. Aggravating corporations is fine, but for people who are not ready to hear about this, we need real consideration and a real offer. However inconsistently, we have tried forcing an agenda they need to comply with already, so now let's try something else
jibalt 17 hours ago [-]
Global warming is an existential threat to human civilization. Those other things aren't.
taneq 17 hours ago [-]
Given the responses to mention of climate change even here, I can see a valid argument for improved education being on the critical path towards reducing greenhouse gas emissions. If people are too ignorant to understand what’s happening and why we need to care, they can’t be part of the solution.
jibalt 15 hours ago [-]
I have no argument with that. Solving the problem has multiple prongs.
kortilla 10 hours ago [-]
No it isn’t, and that hyperbole is the problem. It’s going to lead to possibly quite significant food shortages and mass migration but that’s not existential even if it wipes out 90% of the population.
If the reproduction crisis continues to spread in China to where it is in Japan and eventually the rest of the world, the population collapse from that will be worse than even quite pessimistic climate change models of impact.
CalRobert 2 hours ago [-]
wiping out 90% of the population would destroy civilization.
hax0ron3 17 hours ago [-]
I don't know much about climate change science, so I use epistemological heuristics and reach the conclusion that the spectrum of scientific consensus on the topic is more likely to be correct than denial that there is a problem is likely to be correct.
Despite this, I don't have the time or energy to really care much about climate change. I have more immediate problems. I have bills to pay. I barely think about climate change at all. Maybe it would be different if I had children, but I'm not sure. Children make people care more about the non-immediate future, but they also take time and energy. So it's hard to say.
I'm probably pretty representative of the average person in this regard.
jibalt 17 hours ago [-]
I guess I'm not representative of the average person ... I have no children (just a niece) but I care deeply about the future of human civilization.
etcetcetcetceta 3 hours ago [-]
>but I care deeply about the future of human civilization
Why?
It inevitably ends, and that it existed at all is a marvel or a miracle, that doesn't change just because we go extinct.
echelon 19 hours ago [-]
Catch-22:
Telling them this will make them vote even stronger in the other way. Especially if you call them stupid, selfish, etc.
You have to show them how it impacts eg. the cost of insurance for coastal properties. But even so, this is hard to convey. The people voting aren't feeling it and are told by coastal elites what to care about - changing their opinion in the opposite direction.
Some countries are even going to benefit tremendously from warming, eg. Russia gets more arable land and access to the North Sea, which is fantastic for trade, energy, and defense.
Loquebantur 18 hours ago [-]
I called them neither of that, I pointed out the infantile nature of their reaction.
Telling people the truth evokes all kinds of weird reactions, that doesn't mean you shouldn't do it.
The preservation of our shared prerequisite for our continued existence isn't accurately captured by financial metrics. Pretending it was is a major error.
You start with protecting "people" (you are included?) against supposed accusations of stupidity, only to then go on and paint them (and yourself) as stupid and unable to judge connections and consequences correctly. And even stoop to pointing at whataboutisms of imaginary upsides.
criddell 18 hours ago [-]
> Telling people the truth evokes all kinds of weird reactions, that doesn't mean you shouldn't do it.
Maybe it does mean that. If you want people to listen you need to avoid having them immediately tune you out.
Loquebantur 18 hours ago [-]
If you "immediately tune out" the truth, you tune out reality. What does that make you?
When your child acts in such a way (imagine it trying to kill its pet, which it was tasked with sustaining), what do you do? Entertain its fantasies and accommodate its wishes?
The point here is, you enable people to act in such childish ways by inventing justifications for their behavior. Your own prior behavior might well be the cause of their actions in the first place.
criddell 17 hours ago [-]
I’m not saying people immediately tune out the truth. I’m saying they will immediately tune out you and that has less to do with what you are saying than how you are saying it. The truthiness of the message is pretty much irrelevant.
The oil companies pushed bullshit but they knew how to deliver the message and they were effective. People who want to reduce CO2 emissions have not been effective delivering their message yet they keep trying the same thing over-and-over again.
Loquebantur 16 hours ago [-]
You completely ignore what I said. Why? You parrot a nonsense-trope, but apparently believe it was some kind of hyper-wise insight.
The point here isn't about advertisement. It's about people growing up to take responsibility and become actual adults, not just conceited imaginary ones.
As an adult, you have to judge reality without it being "advertised" to you, without any gift-wrapping and bells and whistles. You paint the populace as infants, to be treated as such. And you get that.
imtringued 9 hours ago [-]
The CO2 reduction people are winning and you're looking at the CO2 industries grasping at straws trying to slow down the inevitable transition as a form of success when it is just managed failure.
The fact that people buy into it just means they hate themselves.
jibalt 17 hours ago [-]
Yes, it's a form of Murc's Law ... only those pointing out bad behavior have agency; those behaving badly don't.
rootusrootus 16 hours ago [-]
> If you "immediately tune out" the truth, you tune out reality. What does that make you?
The winner of democratic elections.
Loquebantur 16 hours ago [-]
Does might make right? No.
A substantial portion of the US populace believes that anyway. They engage in all kinds of childish irrational stuff. But does that mean, you as an adult should encourage them?
You don't teach children by "telling them once and then despair forever".
rootusrootus 15 hours ago [-]
So you can gloat about how right you are, but you will never be in a position where you can make change. Each person decides for themselves what their priority is.
enaaem 6 hours ago [-]
I once had a discussion where I complained how hot it was in Europe, and an American bragged how much hotter the US is in many places, but they have aircon and they just sit inside all the time.
whoanoway 19 hours ago [-]
[dead]
etcetcetcetceta 3 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
neves 16 hours ago [-]
I'm always impressed how people can talk about El Niño without mentioning global warming and the nocive USA decisions to drill more oil and to leave Paris Agreement.
Every climate news should come with the footnote: it is due to CO2 in the atmosphere and USA is, by far, the greatest emmiter per Capita
9rx 20 hours ago [-]
> The risks inherent to weather and climate are growing all the time.
Risk is subjective, so this doesn't mean much without quantifying what you feel is risky to you. Moreover, of all the risks we have heard expressed in the population, there is no unary growth value. There is a change in distribution, and some risks have grown, but some risks have also shrunk. If you are relying on the reader to bring their own idea of what the risks are, this is almost certainly going to be false.
I expect you say this with good intentions, trying to instil fear in the reader to convince them that climate change is something to pay attention to. But this kind of "absolute truth" that doesn't hold up to scrutiny is what actually turns people off paying attention to something that justifiably does warrant attention. Let's do better.
tingletech 20 hours ago [-]
I thought risk was defined as probability times cost (or at least that is what you are trying to minimize in risk management) -- so if the probability of costs goes up, would not also risk? You don't have to enumerate each specific risk to believe that risks are growing.
9rx 19 hours ago [-]
I'd say more commonly we say consequence, but I think you can fairly use cost and consequence interchangeably here. They have similar meaning. However, consequence/cost too are subjective. Thus risk is also subjective. Something cannot be objective if its variables are subjective.
infinite_spin 19 hours ago [-]
Costs are tangible, making them objective, even if they have underlying subjectivities. The cost of milk is objective, even if your purchasing habits are subjective.
9rx 19 hours ago [-]
You are correct that "cost" has more than one definition, but, as already discussed, the one we are talking about equates to consequence, not an amount of money. Your milk analogy doesn't fit. Whether or not a so-called consequence is seen as a consequence is in the eye of the beholder.
infinite_spin 19 hours ago [-]
I'm well aware of the narrowing you imposed. Consequence in these terms still equates to an objective reality, even if the underlying source of it can be described as subjective. The consequences of rising milk prices is an objective reality, even if your purchasing habits are subjective.
9rx 2 hours ago [-]
Consequences are only felt emotionally. Emotions are subjective. The fact that brain activity can be measured is not what anyone means when they speak about subjectivity.
This has nothing to do with buying habits. It seems you're still mixing up definitions. You're not wrong that "cost" has more than one definition, but only one of them applies to risk formulas.
breakyerself 19 hours ago [-]
There is significantly more moisture in the atmosphere now meaning the storms that el nino brings will have a greater capacity to cause flooding. The water the piles up on the west coast of north America will be in addition to the sea level rise that already occurred. Making coastal flooding worse. A drier winter in the Pacific northwest means less snowpack and therefore less water available in the summer with global warming this is exacerbated by the loss of mountain glaciers which help balance seasonal variability. Heating the western Pacific means el nino has always been bad for fisheries there, but layering it on top of global warming can increasingly devastate fish populations there.
Our infrastructure and agriculture are designed around a climate regime that is increasingly becoming a thing of the past. I think your attitude about this shit is nonsensical
EdwardDiego 19 hours ago [-]
The moisture is a side-effect of the additional energy in the atmosphere - warmer gases can hold more water vapour.
And that's the thing - our climate is a massively complex system of interacting systems, and now we've put more energy into it, and it'll show up in the variability.
esalman 20 hours ago [-]
"Risk is subjective" until damages occur to someone and it's time to file an insurance claim.
9rx 20 hours ago [-]
If there is something you don't believe is a risk, who are going to file a claim with? Normally insurers expect you to arrange insurance beforehand, which requires identifying something you believe is a risk.
esalman 18 hours ago [-]
If you have home insurance, climate risk is already priced in when they set your premium.
nsoam 19 hours ago [-]
Yes, that’s the exact definition of subjective
Sharlin 20 hours ago [-]
"Yeah, tens of millions died and hundreds of millions were displaced, but in the meantime we made a lot of value for the shareholders so it wasn't all bad."
Ok Timmy, now that you saw the video of El Niño works, can you explain it in your words?
Timmy: uhhhhhhhh
romanovcode 20 hours ago [-]
Title: A short explainer on how El Niño works in US [video] (youtube.com)
darkwater 19 hours ago [-]
Yeah. I opened it, saw that the map was centered on NA, and I closed it. I was hoping a primer on how El Niño works globally, given the title.
heikkilevanto 20 hours ago [-]
Yes, this was very US centric
slicktux 20 hours ago [-]
Not that the cause is known yet but I’d been curious how this El Niño would affect flying after that terrible Florida Leer Jet crash. Great video!
vibebingo 20 hours ago [-]
I would be curious too. That said each pilot must avoid dangerous weather. There is a recent captain steeeve video where the pilot does that. ATC won't vector them around the storm (not sure why...) so they declare an emergency then they are free to fly as needed to avoid it.
jeffbee 21 hours ago [-]
Actual title is "El Niño Winter 2026–27: What Pilots Should Expect"
-Ed 20 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
warrenmercer25 20 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
jamiek88 20 hours ago [-]
How do we report obvious bots? Created 5 minutes ago, nonsense reply.
Fraterkes 20 hours ago [-]
Always strikes me as bizarre with these bots that even the current cheapest llm's could have written a much more sensical fake reply based on just the title.
The first chapter of Ministry for the Future explores this idea.
I live in a similar climate and I'm pretty sure if it hit 52 millions of people would die and a bunch of equipment would fail.
51 was apparently the highest over here before (Cebu) which was at most 37 degrees in actual temperature.
If the sun's not direct you can manage a few hours without for trouble but I wouldn't want to spend a night without AC.
Those of us who want to see CO2 reductions need to find solutions that don’t lead to inflation in the short term. It’s probably going to be a technological rather than policy solution.
How do you resolve that without involving policy?
Who's "they"?
Also, Trump banned solar?
The current one seems to be doing the same as the old one.
Climate is filled with non linearities and drawing straight lines from the past is a fools errant.
Least we forget the Sahara only turned into a desert when it got less sunshine.
Climate scientists disagree.
> The last El Nino caused an extremely wet summer in Australia despite a century of data pointing in the opposite direction.
No, that occurrence is not inconsistent with the data.
> Climate is filled with non linearities and drawing straight lines from the past is a fools errant.
The word is "errand" and this is absurd ... climate is an average over weather, we can plot a trend line, and that line has an upward slope.
Least honest or intelligent and most refuted denier talking point ever.
https://skepticalscience.com/climate-change-little-ice-age-m...
Now, we're off topic so I won't further discuss where comments get posted.
20,000 years was the peak of the last ice age. Any trend line starting that sooner than that will by definition be increasing. Largely because NYC isn't under 1 mile of glaciers.
https://static.skepticalscience.com/pics/1_All_palaeotemps.p...
Even at +3C we still haven't reached the peaks of the last inter glacial maxima 130,000 years ago.
https://journals.ametsoc.org/view/journals/clim/37/4/JCLI-D-...
>No, that occurrence is not inconsistent with the data.
It is.
>climate is an average over weather, we can plot a trend line, and that line has an upward slope.
Climate over the last billion years has been stable an nothing has happened.
Instead of acknowledging the scientific facts and the ethical implications thereof, they engage in "catch me if you can"-tactics.
They let themselves be willfully utilized as a shield of ignorance against the financial restitution they owe. Not to speak of the implied loss of influence in the world economy after fossil fuels are phased out.
I don’t think that can be the only reason. For over a decade PV has been cheaper than coal^1, but many of the people opposed to reducing climate change have remained staunch supporters of the coal industry.
^1 Yes, some caveats apply, but as PV/renewables continue to fall in price, fewer and fewer do.
The reason why comes down to exergy. In most cases, we can extract more useful work from a kwh of electricity than a kwh of fossil fuels. And people can usually get more food, more useful energy, more transport, and if they want more kids, in a renewables based economy.
This would be true, if only it weren’t for the reality that everywhere renewables have penetrated the market to an extent worth talking about electricity has gotten much more expensive and significant deindustrialisation has occurred, as well as the loss of many small businesses that can no longer survive due to that deindustrialisation and / or those much higher electricity costs.
"Deindustrialization" has little to do with electricity costs. If you're serious please tell us the split between labor and electricity costs for an average car factory in the US, Europe, Japan, and China.
Or you could get battery + solar and it’ll basically just work for a couple decades and then become recyclable. There’s not even a land problem; it would take less land than we currently use for the corn ethanol mixed into gas.
IMO this inverts the real chain of causality: it's because carbon reduction has been connected to material impoverishment.
There's endless propaganda blaring how only endless growth can give us prosperity. If you even think about advocating for decreased energy usage, you want to kill poor people and China to win (I've had both of these thrown at me on HN).
We have a multi-trillion industry who has been pouring billions into psychological manipulation. IMO evaluating statements like the quote in this light makes a whole lot of things make sense.
So if you believe we can do without those, sure.
But we can’t.
Concrete is carbon emissions intensive, if you believe we can do without it, sure.
But we can’t.
Nobody said we should stop producing concrete.
Earth was about 800 million years old when the first signs of life appeared, and it was 3 billion years old before multicellular life appeared. It took another billion years before things like animals and plants appeared (the Cambrian explosion), and since then there's only been like 500 million years of history.
Most mass extinctions have happened in the past 500 million years and have killed off huge swathes of life on the planet, but new lifeforms have come back, on a much shorter timescale than 4 billion years, because it hasn't had to start from scratch. That's what we mean by "fine", and why it would be a problem if all life (even the single celled life) were eradicated.
I seriously doubt the majority of humans agrees that "planet earth will be fine" means "planet earth still has any life left", so that doesn't explain why this is the correct yardstick.
You asked, and got a reasonable answer, which you rejected.
>that doesn't explain why this is the correct yardstick.
Since you seem to have a notion of the "correct yardstick", please share in what ways Planet Earth will not be fine without humans (i.e. your candidates for the correct yardstick).
edit: never mind, I posted this before seeing all your other comments.
This third rock from the sun will happily just keep orbiting on, with or without us, regardless of how much we fart old carbon into the atmosphere.
That's what I don't understand. Are you willfully misinterpreting this statement, or do you really not understand?
Past changes in climate comparable to current global warming did indeed cause global mass extinctions; the most severe was the Permian-Triassic extinction (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permian%E2%80%93Triassic_extin...). However, life did recover ... it just took millions of years to do so.
I disagree, therefore that it is 'useless pedantry' to distinguish between the ecological damage in the short-term that will definitely affect humans, and the long-term where the biosphere _should_ eventually recover. If anything, the large amount of time relative to human-scale should make it more alarming, not less.
To put it another way, I think that there is benefit in de-fusing the ideas of destruction of the Earth and harm to the environment (habitat loss, extinction, etc). I do not particularly care about who "insisted you were wrong", that's up to you.
In any case, skimming through your recent comments, notice a bit of a pattern were our discussions get very argumentative. I wish you all the best, and please forgive me but I encourage you not to think of discussions online as arguments that you have to "win". Do as you wish, but I used to do this, and found it stressful and unhelpful in the long run.
> To put it another way, I think that there is benefit in de-fusing the ideas of destruction of the Earth and harm to the environment (habitat loss, extinction, etc).
I'd love to hear more about what benefit you see in de-fusing these ideas. The reason I even wrote my initial comment is that I see this brought up almost every time anyone mentions "destroying the earth", but I can't remember ever seeing anything productive grow out of this de-fusing. This makes intuitive sense to me: this response does not address the meaning of a message, only the form, which diverts the discussion from the actual topic.
So I'm trying to figure out what I'm missing. What is the benefit of bringing this up almost every time? Unfortunately defrost has been more interested in trolling than answering, so I still don't know. But I'd genuinely love to hear more about your thought process, because I really want to understand your position!
Stop the slander, re-evaluate your priors, reread your own comments - you were so keen to just keep attacking you missed your chance with me .. maybe later.
Collectively we have a fair to bleeding edge grasp of seismology, magnetotellurics, radiometrics, Gravimetry, tidal modelling, geological time, geological strata, etc.
Are you wilfully misinterpreting these things, or do you really not understand?
I didn't ask the question for fun. You seem to be deliberately misinterpreting the statement by rustcleaner. Why? Why not keep to the HN guidelines, and actually respond to their point? As a reminder:
> Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith.
People that study the planet, as opposed to the biosphere.
Could you maybe not do that? It's not funny or insightful, it just sucks the air out of discussions.
It is very clear, to native english speakers at least, that was exactly the distinction made above: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50515074
Could you maybe not do that? It's not funny or insightful, it just sucks the air out of discussions.
This is exactly the kind of useless pedantry I'm talking about! It's a completely normal way of speaking, which native english speakers should have encountered countless times: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metonymy
You might not like seeing this figure of speech, but can't you just pull yourself together and not post the same useless "correction" for the millionth time?
For a great many people, what you call "useless pedantry" is an important distinction - in the history of planet earth a number of lifeforms have come and gone.
Should humans alter the insulation factor to such a degree than they disrupt the very biosphere that supports them, that's bad for humans.
As far as planet earth goes, it's another wave of life crashing, with others to follow.
"The planet will not literally blow up" is not an important distinction for anyone.
But I've already wasted far too much time with your poor trolling attempts, please do your "I am very smart" schtick somewhere else.
You asked a question, I answered in good faith, and you've done little other than sling bile since.
Here's an interesting paper: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S036031992...
it's about something that may very well help a human centric biosphere .. but, you know, it came from people that make a distinction between planetary studies and biosphere studies in order to have a better understanding.
Reality doesn't allow for any such thing and wishing for it doesn't make it so.
Consequently, ignoring that reality will see you running into a wall head-on. With wildly devastating consequences: El Niño is just one immediate symptom, look at the AMOC. It collapsing will see about 70% or more of Earth's population wiped out. Along with the corresponding capacity for crop growth.
What you need to do is actually preventing foreseeable calamities, not complaining about people pointing you at them.
People in communism, or nearly any other socioeconomic system, also want more housing, transport, food, energy, and children.
Reality includes public opinion, which even authoritarian systems have to account for to some extent. So even if the reality is that climate change will be so devastating that it needs to be addressed by any means necessary (I don't know if that is the reality, but let's say for the sake of argument that it is), that necessity has to be sold to people somehow.
And it's difficult to convince people to accept impoverishment if the truly major negative consequences of not acting on climate change are ones that will not happen for decades, as seems to be the case at least in temperate regions. I know very little about AMOC, but it seems the science about AMOC collapse timelines is not settled enough to convince the average person that something must be done immediately.
To get public buy-in in such a situation, it may be more advantageous to figure out how to be able to sell the necessary changes in a way that is not accompanied by impoverishment. That or ignore public buy-in, but then one still has to figure out how to do that. Voters punish economic decline. And I doubt that there is a realistic path to replacing Western democracy with an authoritarian system that has climate change as a top priority, at least in the near future.
> consequences of not acting [...] are ones that will not happen for decades
Are you aware of the movie "Don't look up"? Because if not, it might be worth a watch before reading your own comment again. If so, I really wonder what your interpretation of the movie was, since, to me, your comment reads pretty much exactly like how that movie plays out.
Note how absurd the framing here is: "impoverishment" of whom and meaning what? US Americans, among the richest in the world, "falling" to the average? Who is supposed to pity them exactly?
Your idea of "consequences not happening for decades": WTF? So, so long as its not you who bears the downsides, you don't care? How sympathetic.
"Public buy in" is a chimera. You propose, they would buy into anything they're being told, so long as it sounds attractive to them. What's that supposed to mean?
Either, the public believes anything they're being told anyway, or they have to actually grow up and learn to know the truth themselves. It's not about whatever nonsense "political system", it's about epistemology.
As for the AMOC timeline: you could use your own rational mind to figure that out, but you prefer for others to tell you. Unless they tell you what you don't want to hear? Seriously?
We already produce too much of virtually everything, and that's the whole problem.
-Greek proverb you've probably heard before
Who are making their societies great again, I hear!
I'm not sure we "need" more people driving a 2.5 ton studio apartment 40 miles to work each way through the desert.
It’s a lie that decarbonization is going to result in material impoverishment. “Oh my things!!”
It hasn’t worked.
Unless you consider an alarm rising in families living in tents ”working,” but you’d be the only one.
We can have expensive “renewables” (they’re not) if, as Jimmy Carr says, “you don’t give a fuck about poor people.”
I don't know what you're getting out of so much lying.
saving our species
The earth will do fine, and probably better, once we extinct ourselves
Humans aren't mindless animals, helplessly falling prey to their basic instincts. Claiming as much is an utter absurdity, that should become obvious when observing how selectively that deflection is being used.
"Lifestyle", convenience and "just not getting the long term aspects", those are simply lies. People know perfectly well.
The problem is, they've been taught it was OK for them to act like children, shirking responsibility. They're being covered for by comments like yours.
there are entire subcultures built on exposing the very "basic instincts" that a considerable majority of us humans fall for. these subcultures are called "religions." all of them attempt to control these "instincts" through concepts such as a "deadly sin".
some things pretty much are the human nature. we make miracles not out of desire for utopia but when we are under a gun. and this particular one is pretty big. extinction-level, I'd say.
They’re ignoring it because they can, and fuck you.
Trying to convince them is pointless because it isn’t about that, and never was.
All you’re doing is wasting your time and showing even more people that their approach “works”.
Hint: scolding the highshool bully about the short term stupidity and bad ethics about their bullying also doesn’t do anything.
Interesting way to frame the constraints of reality.
It’s not far from what I’ve always thought. We simply will not solve these problems with broad self-denial. It’s an absurd notion, even if the monastic sheen of it sounds nice.
Even when adjusting for trade, it is down considerably over the last 20 years. Mainly due to dematerialization, basically a free market economy doing more with less (e.g. efficient packaging uses less materials and is cheaper).
US and the Western world can continue reducing carbon emissions and it won't make a bit of difference.
Try spending 5 minutes on google before you spout uniformed opinions
https://ourworldindata.org/profile/co2/united-states
https://ourworldindata.org/consumption-based-co2
Things might have improved from 20 years ago but the more recent governmental trend is not positive.
See HN guidelines, specifically in respect to polite discourse, and perhaps steelman their claim.
By "outsize responsibility" they likely refer to the fact that still today the US as a country has been the source of the largest per country contribution to AGW gases (burnt fossil fuels).
They might also refer to 1970s US capitalists (eg: Koch brothers) doubling down hard on climate denial after the papers of 1967 and actively funding think tanks to push civic development towards roads, away from public transport, and make bigger cars sexy.
To this day the cumulative total of fossil gases uplifted by the USofA still exceeds that of China - despite the smaller population of the USofA.
How much of China's CO2 is a result of the products Americans buy that were manufactured in China?
If we look at CO2 as a result of consumption it would tell a truer story.
Still their emissions. They could choose not to subsidize their industry in pursuit of being manufacturer for the whole world. They do not get to dodge accountability by blaming it on their customers.
On the flip side, we should not take away agency from those who choose to favor increased export industry over increased emissions. That is an active choice. Same if they allow poor employment safety or child labor. The importer of goods has some moral responsibility to buy from someone else (even if its more expensive), but the absolute majority of responsibility is on the country that exports. Emission numbers can't be white washed by claiming that it goes to exports, as if being paid to do it means less responsibility (a very strange notion to begin with).
There are manufacturing processes that use a lot of energy, and the US does a lot of that (maybe more than China) because it has low energy costs.
This paints the Chinese as some used puppets of the capitalist West. They would rather hug trees and live on sustainable organic farms but the evil capitalists came and forced them to burn coal and make cheap plastic toys for them. This is removes their agency (individual or government, either way) and I don’t think it’s a fair characterization.
The state of the climate is due to the accumulation of CO2 in Earth's atmosphere. You pretend, those past emissions didn't happen. Also, global emissions expanded dramatically over the last 25 years.
The U.S. share of global annual CO2 emissions "peaked" at roughly 55% in 1918 during the height of early American industrialization. Obviously, that's an absurd comparison to mention here. What matters is the overall contribution in actual metric tons.
U.S. emissions are not currently dropping without interruption. After falling roughly 18% to 20% from their 2005 - 2007 peak, U.S. emissions rebounded in 2025, increasing by 2.4% to 3.2% due to colder winter weather, rising electricity demand from data centers, and a 13% jump in coal-fired power generation.
The claim that emissions fell mainly due to "dematerialization" and free-market packaging efficiency is largely inaccurate. While economic efficiency played a supporting role, energy sector transitions were the dominant driver. The reductions were driven primarily by replacing coal with natural gas and renewables in the power sector.
And that's all completely ignoring the systemic influence the US has had and still has.
I don't think Loquebantur had any sort of constructive purpose in starting their subthread. I think they are pushing an ideological agenda.
Was global warming established as a serious risk in 1918?
You've got a specific set of ideological commitments and conclusions, and instead of arguing for them, you leapt directly into psychoanalyzing why people don't already agree with you. It's very annoying.
These people are not arguing in good faith.
It'd better to avoid country V country pissing contests and focus on global efforts. In a real sense the cost of going solar, wind, renewable powered is Chinese emissions .. for now.
Sorry, great grand-children. Pipelines gotta pump.
This is arguably the correct thing, even if you believe the situation is urgent, if you also believe that other things are more urgent. Suppose you think that fixing declining education or economies is absolutely prerequisite, and that until people are smarter or more comfortable or both, even discussing the climate too often weakens your chances of building effective coalitions.
Personally, I go back and forth when I weigh this sort of thing, I'm really not sure. We probably need to at least consider that this is a consistent/coherent perspective. Of course, it's not a invitation to make things worse as fast as possible with drill-baby-drill.. but an acknowledgement that there are many other ways to make things worse, such as pissing people off. Aggravating corporations is fine, but for people who are not ready to hear about this, we need real consideration and a real offer. However inconsistently, we have tried forcing an agenda they need to comply with already, so now let's try something else
If the reproduction crisis continues to spread in China to where it is in Japan and eventually the rest of the world, the population collapse from that will be worse than even quite pessimistic climate change models of impact.
Despite this, I don't have the time or energy to really care much about climate change. I have more immediate problems. I have bills to pay. I barely think about climate change at all. Maybe it would be different if I had children, but I'm not sure. Children make people care more about the non-immediate future, but they also take time and energy. So it's hard to say.
I'm probably pretty representative of the average person in this regard.
Why?
It inevitably ends, and that it existed at all is a marvel or a miracle, that doesn't change just because we go extinct.
Telling them this will make them vote even stronger in the other way. Especially if you call them stupid, selfish, etc.
You have to show them how it impacts eg. the cost of insurance for coastal properties. But even so, this is hard to convey. The people voting aren't feeling it and are told by coastal elites what to care about - changing their opinion in the opposite direction.
Some countries are even going to benefit tremendously from warming, eg. Russia gets more arable land and access to the North Sea, which is fantastic for trade, energy, and defense.
Telling people the truth evokes all kinds of weird reactions, that doesn't mean you shouldn't do it.
The preservation of our shared prerequisite for our continued existence isn't accurately captured by financial metrics. Pretending it was is a major error.
You start with protecting "people" (you are included?) against supposed accusations of stupidity, only to then go on and paint them (and yourself) as stupid and unable to judge connections and consequences correctly. And even stoop to pointing at whataboutisms of imaginary upsides.
Maybe it does mean that. If you want people to listen you need to avoid having them immediately tune you out.
When your child acts in such a way (imagine it trying to kill its pet, which it was tasked with sustaining), what do you do? Entertain its fantasies and accommodate its wishes?
The point here is, you enable people to act in such childish ways by inventing justifications for their behavior. Your own prior behavior might well be the cause of their actions in the first place.
The oil companies pushed bullshit but they knew how to deliver the message and they were effective. People who want to reduce CO2 emissions have not been effective delivering their message yet they keep trying the same thing over-and-over again.
The point here isn't about advertisement. It's about people growing up to take responsibility and become actual adults, not just conceited imaginary ones.
As an adult, you have to judge reality without it being "advertised" to you, without any gift-wrapping and bells and whistles. You paint the populace as infants, to be treated as such. And you get that.
The fact that people buy into it just means they hate themselves.
The winner of democratic elections.
A substantial portion of the US populace believes that anyway. They engage in all kinds of childish irrational stuff. But does that mean, you as an adult should encourage them?
You don't teach children by "telling them once and then despair forever".
Every climate news should come with the footnote: it is due to CO2 in the atmosphere and USA is, by far, the greatest emmiter per Capita
Risk is subjective, so this doesn't mean much without quantifying what you feel is risky to you. Moreover, of all the risks we have heard expressed in the population, there is no unary growth value. There is a change in distribution, and some risks have grown, but some risks have also shrunk. If you are relying on the reader to bring their own idea of what the risks are, this is almost certainly going to be false.
I expect you say this with good intentions, trying to instil fear in the reader to convince them that climate change is something to pay attention to. But this kind of "absolute truth" that doesn't hold up to scrutiny is what actually turns people off paying attention to something that justifiably does warrant attention. Let's do better.
This has nothing to do with buying habits. It seems you're still mixing up definitions. You're not wrong that "cost" has more than one definition, but only one of them applies to risk formulas.
Our infrastructure and agriculture are designed around a climate regime that is increasingly becoming a thing of the past. I think your attitude about this shit is nonsensical
And that's the thing - our climate is a massively complex system of interacting systems, and now we've put more energy into it, and it'll show up in the variability.
It's updated daily with the latest data. He also has a new "El Niño Impacts" tab here: https://dashboard.theclimatebrink.com/#impacts
https://climatereanalyzer.org/clim/sst_daily
https://youtu.be/DutKGuQu4a0
France isn't very much affected, so it's not focused on any country.
https://youtu.be/tWhcTTC-pyw
Timmy: uhhhhhhhh