You don't need a fancy glass. Your sense of smell makes a huge difference when it comes to food and drink, as anybody with a nasty cold can tell you. You want something that keeps it from diffusing into the air so anything with a wide mouth makes it harder to appreciate.
So: a cognac snifter; sherry glass; a glencairn, which was ""made for whisky""; etc.
But of course it's down to taste.
If the aroma is too heady? Blow air into glass and then inhale the aroma. The burn is gone (important if you're drinking 62% rocket fuel single cask whisky) and you get a more dilute smell.
No need for all this pretension; this glass is that.
crystaln 13 hours ago [-]
You don’t need a fancy glass. However the glass does affect the taste and nose experience.
Have you ever tasted red wine from a proper wine glass next to a regular cup and noticed how the wine hits a different part of your pallet? How the thickness of the glass affects the experience? How the size and shape affects the aroma?
These are real things, none of which you need.
You don’t need audiophile speakers to listen to music, but if you’re an audiophile or even anyone with good hearing, your experience is going to be different with better speakers.
You don’t need a fancy pizza oven to make good pizza, but you can make better pizza - at least of certain kinds - with one.
You can be a “serious whiskey collector” and not care about the glass, just like you can be a serious fan of music and not care about the speakers, or a serious hiker and not care about your attire, or serious golfer and not care about your clubs or balls, etc etc.
Maybe more applicable here, you can be a great software developer and write in PHP.
I drink whiskey and wine from whatever glass is in close reach, however when that happens to be a proper glass, I definitely notice.
So please don’t cast your disdain on people who care about the nuances of their experience, no matter how nice your whiskey collection is.
mickeyp 10 hours ago [-]
I said the mouth of the glass matters - that is the only part that does. I even listed glasses that are great: cognac, sherry, glencairn. So I'm not sure what point you're making?
The rest of your argumentation are points I've never made, and many (aside from the audiophile one, which is mostly bunkum) like that wood-fired pizza oven is better is of course true in abstract for bread and pizza making.
D-Machine 9 hours ago [-]
You are right. You made exactly clear what needed to be made clear to the amateur, and to someone who has played around with these things, you also made clear the most important parts (i.e. narrowed mouth). Everything beyond that is a tiny optimization.
theturtletalks 2 hours ago [-]
Did you read the article? He mentions that other glasses get the work done just right. His glass is not just about the mouth, the curves allow the alcohol to “leave” so the aroma can be better enjoyed.
But doing this makes the drink weaker so he set out to make a glass that gives you the best of both worlds. He even went around the US to distilleries and masters of bourbons and they could tell the difference.
He also said he’s not trying to sell this to the places he visited. He thinks that restaurants could start offering different whiskey glasses akin to how they do with wine down the line.
Antipode 1 hours ago [-]
Unless blind tests were performed you can't eliminate expectation bias.
nkrisc 3 hours ago [-]
How does the thickness of the glass affect the experience?
shevy-java 3 hours ago [-]
Well - if the glass is so thick that you can not hold it in both hands ...
rlander 15 hours ago [-]
Also a “serious drinker” here. I stopped caring about my whisky glass during my first trip to Scotland. Up until then, I would feel slightly offended to be served a good whisky in anything other than a glencairn or a copita. But throughout the trip (which involved mostly high end warehouse tastings), I noticed that nobody really cared about the glass. At each distillery I’d get a random glass (sometimes a copita, sometimes a glencairn, a lot of times something else) and, between drams, they would just direct us to tap water to clean our glasses. They cared about the whisky, not the container.
stewh_eng 8 hours ago [-]
The smell experience is being among the angel's share!
When you're next in Scotland, check the weather forecast. Look for a period of gentle <5mph wind pushing the evaporated whiskey from the distillery and bond houses into some trees or hills nearby. Scotland is usually quite a windy place so you'll need to time it. If you're in the central belt, Dumgoyne distillery has this often when you start the walk up the hill behind it. I've also experienced this walking in the forest immediately behind the Ben Nevis distillery. No need for fancy glasses... just go and enjoy the open air experience!
bradrn 4 hours ago [-]
> Dumgoyne distillery
Pedantic note: Dumgoyne is the hill behind the distillery; the distillery itself is Glengoyne.
mr_mitm 7 hours ago [-]
I can confirm. I got served whisky in a tumbler in Scotland more often than anywhere else. Unfortunately, while I'm not picky about the glass, I draw the line at a tumbler. As the GP explained, the alcohol overwhelms the senses when drinking from a tumbler.
russdill 13 hours ago [-]
I went to a very upscale members only whiskey tasting club in Edinburgh. Money was clearly spent. But nothing special about the glasses, and to add any water to open it up, just regular push button drinking fountains.
I did really get the impression that serious whiskey drinkers do not care for pretension.
dannybaws 5 hours ago [-]
Pretty sure since you were in Edinburgh, it would have in fact been a whisky tasting club ;)
seanhandley 4 hours ago [-]
I agree, as a longtime collector and whisky blogger, the glassware is not especially relevant. But most people taste interesting whisky as an emotional experience, rather than a scientific one, and the glassware is part of the overall ritual.
I wouldn't buy one of these, but I understand why others would.
mattbrewsbytes 4 hours ago [-]
As with any food or drink that a human would like to convince others that its elevated (aka better than similar ones) there needs to be pretension and gatekeeping.
An interesting deep dive would be when this came about with humans, was there "mead with notes of huckleberry" in medieval times or did it start farther back in history? When did this concept originate? Is it called by different names in different cultures?
1 days ago [-]
amiga386 14 hours ago [-]
On the other hand, if you want to maximise pretension, drink from a quaich (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quaich). Exceptionally ceremonial but it does nothing for the taste.
smallnix 1 days ago [-]
> No need for all this pretension
> a cognac snifter ... a glencairn
I think it's all relative.
mickeyp 1 days ago [-]
My point is that all your senses play a role. Which comes as a surprise to no one, I am sure. That is why I caveated that by making it clear that if you have a cold your nose often can't smell well, and that the mouth -- and how easily the volatiles can reach the interior of your nose -- is important, but that literally any glass that funnels them is good enough.
transitorykris 12 hours ago [-]
As kids we learned if you hold your nose the medicine doesn’t taste so bad.
thereisnospork 1 days ago [-]
You don't, but sometimes the pretension is just part of the fun.
close04 1 days ago [-]
I agree with all you said. Except... some whimsy might truly make people enjoy the thing more.
Like audiophile cables, the placebo effect contributes to the experience. Or maybe it’s the lack of nocebo that helps. Either way, someone convinced the whiskey tastes better from that glass will actually taste something better in their subjective experience.
mickeyp 1 days ago [-]
Whimsy's totally fine. By all means indulge: buy the glasses you like, which is kinda my point. But I think there's, much like audio, an awful lot of overwrought marketing that could make people think they must own this dude's ugly glasses --- in whisky a lot of the "mystique" come from the distilleries themselves and the mythology they've manufactured around the whole experience of drinking it.
phs318u 21 hours ago [-]
I’ve been drinking whiskey seriously for several decades and been doing so out of one these [0] for most of that time. Having done many side-by-side taste tests with my friends over the years (I started with a pair of glasses, now down to one), we all agree the burn is noticeably less. Is it a double-blind experiment? No. Could placebo be in effect? Quite possibly. But I can only report what I’ve experienced - the burn is less.
Entire fashion business is just emotions for example. Dont underestimate that part of humans
BigTTYGothGF 16 hours ago [-]
I always just drank it straight from the bottle.
criddell 1 hours ago [-]
In a lot of movies (like many James Bond movies) they pour some brown liquor from a crystal decanter into a glass. I immediately imagine that person (maybe Ralph Fiennes or Daniel Craig) in their kitchen with a funnel and a fresh bottle of scotch refilling the decanter and that seems funny and absurd to me. It pretty much wipes out the aura factor of the decanter.
Glug, glug, glug, glug.
crystaln 13 hours ago [-]
So unrefined. I top off my soda can for classy discretion.
Isamu 2 hours ago [-]
Everybody knows that the most refined corn whiskey comes in a stoneware jug with XXX on the outside
The perfect whiskey glass already exists - the "Norlan Glass," which sits in a beautiful middle between the prissy Glencairn and the manly, chunky rocks glass.
Now, I haven't owned one of these for years, because my wife put both of mine in the dishwasher and broke them. $32 for one glass is too much for me to stomach given my middling level of interest in whiskey these days, and a rocks glass is good enough. But they were damn fine glasses. Someday when I'm rich and famous, I'll buy some more.
ricardobeat 3 hours ago [-]
You can buy similar double walled glasses at IKEA now, for $5 each.
Those are quite nice, though they do lack the distinctive inner shape of the Glencairn / Norlan. But I bet they're more than sufficient for directing some whiskey smells to your nose and at a 10th of the price, it's hard to get too uppity about the subtle difference.
Nice shout!
nemomarx 13 hours ago [-]
Can I ask why whisky glasses have such thick walls? Is it a thermal insulation thing with the double walls, or is there something else? I've seen it across various styles.
regentbowerbird 8 hours ago [-]
Old-fashioned glasses have thick walls and/or fat bottoms because that is the style for them. "Cut glass" decoration requires some thickness.
Norlan is double-walled in order to keep let the drinker sip their whisky without it warming up. A lot of people drink their whisky cold, both because it softens the attack and also because it changes the taste a bit, and whisky drinking is all about drinking the same thing over and over again and discovering new things each time.
As a side note Norlan glasses are borosilicate and therefore perfectly appropriate for hot beverages. I suspect they might actually be some of the best tea tasting glasses available although I haven't tried it out yet.
epiccoleman 12 hours ago [-]
I don't have a real answer, and my OP is half in jest, but there is something that feels a little nicer to me about a chunky heavy rocks glass in comparison to the more "delicate" wine glass (or the Glencairn).
The Norlan glass I linked above is actually thinner walled - the "chunkiness" just comes from the double-wall. (And I'd be happier to buy a new set if the glass was thicker, which would have saved my aforementioned set from being killed by ... water, in the dishwasher).
mr_mitm 7 hours ago [-]
The owner of whisky.com, an engineer who funded one of the first online whisky shops, made a supposedly ideal glass like an engineer would while completely ignoring the role aesthetics play in enjoying whisky: https://www.whisky.de/shop/en/product/ZGLWDE0UNT.html
I think the reasons for his choices are overblown and the glass looks ugly.
Created by Finnish molecular chemistry PhDs. The shape looks like it too (an industrial designer would never approve this asymmetric lumpiness). But it does make a tangible difference.
lrasinen 1 days ago [-]
Dunno, Finnish glass design has pretty knobly stuff. Iittala's Ultima Thule springs to mind.
lrasinen 1 days ago [-]
My personal favorite is the Gaissa on-the-rocks glass whose bottom is made lumpy to resemble ice.
Looks absolutely amazing with clear drinks on the rocks (duh).
ReptileMan 1 days ago [-]
How do you wash this monstrosity? With laboratory glassware cleaning kit equipment?
pavlov 1 days ago [-]
Regular dishwasher machine.
zug_zug 2 hours ago [-]
Pretty sure this is an ad.
shevy-java 3 hours ago [-]
A very important topic.
Stealthisbook 1 days ago [-]
Solo cup
Stitch4223 1 days ago [-]
Agreed, the invention of the Conex cup [1] by Illinois Tool Works, especially the C10 [2], marked the date when whiskey became drinkable.
There are definitely real advantages to the design. I’m especially fond of the flared lip; it avoids agitating the beer and making it aggressively bubble as you sip.
All this to say, this article isn’t entirely bullshit. But if Zalto is truly successful, there will be plenty of clones vying to replace the standard snifter.
TacticalCoder 1 days ago [-]
For SciFi fans, there is only one true whiskey glass and it doesn't share power:
I don't drink enough for this to be worth it but damn, they are pretty cool.
mk_stjames 12 hours ago [-]
I own several of these and have given them to others as gifts.
They are massive.. chunky to hold... wide mouthed... basically all the things that people in the article and here are saying are negative features for a whiskey glass...
And yet they are my favorite pieces of glassware. Nothing even comes close; I bring them out for special occasions and it always just feels.. special.. to drink from one.
I dunno, is it just the nostalgia for the film? Would I think the same thing if I had never seen Blade Runner before and someone just gave me the glass? Maybe, maybe not. Doesn't matter. Absolutely love the things.
nickpp 1 days ago [-]
It amazes me how accepted and ingrained in our lifestyle is consumption of one drug (alcohol). With attached rituals, passions, hobbies and dedication. It is acceptable to discuss it with pretty much anybody, in any setting.
Meanwhile other, much less harmful drugs (THC, psylocibin) are shunned, judged, even illegal.
There is so much hypocrisy and double standards in our rules that one wonders if we are a rational species at all.
hristov 14 hours ago [-]
In my opinion both thc and psylocibin are much more dangerous than alcohol. Just putting this out there to counteract the endless and persistent droning from the addicts hoping to get their substances cheaper.
I am not arguing against legalisation of weed but the weed they have now will really screw you up and psychedelics can push right into psychosis.
stldev 9 hours ago [-]
Fortunately for the rest of us, it's not subject to your opinion. We have actual data.
Nearly 200,000 people will die this year in the US alone as a result of alcohol. Want to take a guess at expected THC and Psilocybin deaths?
jareklupinski 1 days ago [-]
caffeine - coffee
nicotine - cigarettes
to some extent, dopamine - chocolate
my great-grandparents could even buy cocaine in a drugstore in their time
lo_zamoyski 15 hours ago [-]
[dead]
OroPla 1 days ago [-]
Nevermind alcohol, at least that is restricted to adults. But just look at how we treat sugar! If it is processed food, there's sugar in it.
Guess addictions aren't problematic as long as they do not affect productivity.
lo_zamoyski 15 hours ago [-]
And productivity would be reduced why? Because rational faculties are impeded.
In any case, if that were the only concern, then I claim you would likely not see the legalizing or loosening of restrictions. On the contrary, I claim that this growing laxity is at least subconsciously if not explicitly motivated by a fear of growing discontent over our oligarchic political order, and the desire to “neutralize” the nasty effects of the disordered lifestyles it encourages and to render people docile.
1 days ago [-]
NorrisFByrd 10 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
alienbaby 15 minutes ago [-]
this smells like a thinly disguised 'buy your dad a whisky glass for christmas' ad
tiffanyh 2 hours ago [-]
For a company so focused on perfecting the drink, I'm surprised they are offering both stem and stemless glasses for Whisky.
Stemless dramatically changes the profile of the drink since now your hand is warming it (hence why chilled wines are always served in stem glasses).
SeanDav 2 hours ago [-]
This to my philistine brain, sounds a lot like the audiophiles who back in the day used to argue that gold plated connectors were somehow able to deliver better sound...from a digitally generated source!
Sure, things like a wide glass vs a testtube would make a (probably small) difference but beyond gross differences, I struggle to take these sorts of conversations seriously.
rainbowzootsuit 1 days ago [-]
Mr. Zalto also recommended to me some $5,000 speaker cables. I could only afford the left channel so far. I really hope that the effects kick in when I get the right channel cable installed.
OroPla 1 days ago [-]
Having the cable alone isn't enough. You also need these weird plastic things that raise it a few inches up from the ground. Audiophile scams are hilarious.
ndsipa_pomu 1 days ago [-]
Pfffft! You only get the real effect of the music in mono.
fergie 4 hours ago [-]
> Mr. Zalto says it is especially attuned to bourbon and rye
So in other words, not optimised for actual scotch whisky.
NoboruWataya 4 hours ago [-]
In fairness, the word "whisky" does not appear anywhere in the article, so I don't think there was any suggestion it is optimised for scotch.
theDoug 1 days ago [-]
NYT continues to be a great venue for marketing your high-end products, including running your own photos. All while providing the thinnest layer of “but not all agree” counterpoints which only strengthen the perception that this is a product for not the riff raff but truly a thing “for those who know.”
stdbrouw 1 days ago [-]
I mean, this is the Food and Dining section. Like any lifestyle section it is focused on fun and interesting and delightful things, not critical journalism. Some, though not all of it is written to pair well with advertising for luxury goods. There is no deception, that's just what it is. Admittedly all of that's more obvious if you browse to the article from the homepage or if you see it in the printed newspaper, but... it's also just kind of obvious from the moment you start reading?
Also, 1 out of 5 images/videos were provided by the company itself, the other 4 credit people who work for or at the NYT.
yeah, and my thought is that at this price point a key target audience is one of these higher end whiskey bars mentioned so they can differentiate themselves a touch above the rest.
adrianN 1 days ago [-]
I wonder whether they try do use objective measures at all when designing the glasses or whether it’s all vibes and impossible-to-blind taste tests.
bell-cot 1 days ago [-]
He's in the glassware business - how is profit not an objective measure?
classified 1 days ago [-]
Does his profit depend on actual properties of the glass or on his ability to convince buyers that the alleged difference is worth the price? Or that it's a fashionable status symbol for those who can afford it? After all, the glass would probably be wasted if you only drank cheap swill out of it.
bell-cot 1 days ago [-]
It's multi-variable optimization, not either/or. You need to make the product good enough to get serious experts admitting that it has real virtues, and distinctive enough to boldly differentiate from your competitors while getting a good placebo effect, and play up the social status.
And notice the very long, thin stem in the picture? That'll maximize breakage, so your customers need to keep buying more glasses.
optionalsquid 1 days ago [-]
Quackery like homeopathy shows that the product doesn't need to actually do what it claims to do, the mere perception that it does is enough to sell a product
bell-cot 1 days ago [-]
The meme-propagation and profit-optimization spaces for medical treatment bear no resemblance to those for whiskey glassware:
- Medical treatment is a universal essential for life & health. Whiskey glassware is a niche luxury purchase.
- Creating a pretty-effective whiskey glass can be done, reliably, on a small budget. Vs. creating a pretty-effective medical treatment, and getting the approvals needed to sell it as such? Yeah.
- Medical treatment has a huge conventional medicine establishment - which is notorious for being unable to provide effective treatment for patients with many sorts of chronic problems. And is all too often contemptuously dismissive of their complaints. Which gives alternative medicine a huge pipeline of prospective customers, and the immediate cheap win of just taking their complaints seriously.
optionalsquid 1 days ago [-]
Perhaps audiophile gear is a better comparison; could I tempt you with some nice rocks with which to improve your audio quality?
Maybe stems have a few benefits - but with all the shapes and colors of the bottles that liquor comes in, I'd figure that distinctive looks are an objective themselves.
ndsipa_pomu 21 hours ago [-]
Yeah, I've got nothing against fancy glasses, though some are just impractical with narrow tubes etc. Long stems just seem unnecessarily fragile and top heavy.
ChoGGi 2 hours ago [-]
Keeps your body temperature away from the drink.
dfxm12 1 days ago [-]
Enjoyment of food/drink is subjective. Even if you could measure that a glass objectively better in some measure, who is to say that leads to everyone, or even anyone, enjoying their whisky more?
adrianN 1 days ago [-]
Sure, but if the claim is that this glass shape somehow reduces ethanol aroma, I’d expect sampling the gas at the mouth of the glass using a facsimile nose and checking how much ethanol is in there. To use the comparison from the article, what sound system makes your favorite song sound best is subjective, but the frequency response of the loudspeakers can be measured objectively and optimized to your preferences.
13 hours ago [-]
kart23 1 days ago [-]
i really don’t understand wine or alcohol snobs in general. to me, ingredients and food freshness is so much easier to actually discern and objectively easier to say what food tastes better than arguing over fine minute notes in drinks. a pastry hot out of the oven will taste miles better than one made 4 hours ago and reheated, but it’s pretty hard to find truly fresh baked goods in a lot of places. (donuts especially are amazing less minutes after frying!)
fruit has huge differences in taste depending on the specific variety, where it’s grown, how long ago it was picked, especially stuff like stone fruit or berries. meat, fish, etc also have huge differences in quality and taste.
but maybe i just haven’t had the right glassware :)
beloch 1 days ago [-]
I have three recommendations:
1. Do what makes you happy.
2. Don't make other people feel bad for not being as discerning/picky as you about something.
3. Becoming more discerning about something may make you happy at times, but it may also cost you money and turn a simple pleasure into an unsatisfying pursuit. Choose your obsessions carefully! You can choose not to care.
You probably have friends who, by your standards, are shamefully oblivious to the quality of fruit they eat. If they're happy don't spoil it for them.
The stuff aficionados do does tend to make a difference up to a point. It's not all BS. However, there is typically a diminishing returns curve. Often, there is also some self-deception or outright snake-oil further up the curve.
The only argument I'd make for getting picky about whisky is that you can enjoy the equivalent of a shot for an hour or more. Not as pretense. I mean genuinely enjoying the smell of it for that long and slowly sipping it. It's a way to drink without drinking much. My experience is that glasses do make a difference, but only if you like whisky on its own (or with a few drops of water) at room temperature. If you prefer cocktails or whisky on the rocks, whisky-specific glasses are probably something you don't need to worry about.
Remember recommendations #1 and #3 before you go any further! If you're happy, stay happy! It's okay to choose not to care about whisky. If you can choose not to drink alcohol at all you're probably better off.
nagaiaida 1 days ago [-]
> fruit has huge differences in taste depending on the specific variety, where it’s grown, how long ago it was picked, especially stuff like stone fruit or berries.
alcohol is usually a far better solvent than water for the compounds providing those nuances. if you want to enjoy those flavors out of situ, hello alcohol
1 days ago [-]
globular-toast 1 days ago [-]
Yeah, I agree. I tried the whole whisky/whiskey thing in my early 20s. Had a few different single malts and some famous blends like Johnnie Walker and even had some proper glasses. I also went to some tasting sessions, so I'd tasted upwards of 20 different whiskies overall.
Even compared to beer it's just not that interesting. It felt a bit culty at times, to be honest. But then there's the fact that most people get drunk off the stuff. I stopped doing most drugs before I hit 30. Alcohol was the first to go, being the most boring with the worst side effects. Once you get rid of that there's not a lot left really.
> donuts especially are amazing less minutes after frying!
Oh, absolutely! They are probably my favourite baked item, but I won't even bother unless I can actually see the dough so into the fryer. Unfortunately it's incredibly rare to find a good one. Most are loaded with sugary nonsense to compensate for them not being fresh. Interestingly, in the UK, a country known for obesity, foods like doughnuts where you can see frying process are properly out of fashion. But in nearby Spain, a much thinner country, they have no problem with churros and tortillas etc. It's a shame because doughnuts are far superior.
pseudosaid 1 days ago [-]
The self importance really brings out the nuanced self congratulatory notes. People like a thing and want to hype it up in their own way. Look at audiophiles, who use music to listen to their gear. Anybody can hear but few seek to listen to where the weight is
chalmovsky 1 days ago [-]
De gustibus non est disputandum, but for me, what matters most about a whisky is not "Is it in a correct glass?" but “Is it an Islay?”
sandworm101 7 hours ago [-]
And how many will buy these fancy glasses but still not bother to learn how to hold them? A long neck has a purpose. A short neck another. A cup without a neck a third method. Dont ignore the design.
ReptileMan 1 days ago [-]
Next generation will just be Claisen flask. Or Soxhlet .
kittikitti 3 hours ago [-]
Why is this on Hacker News? This isn't relevant at all. It's also the New York Times?!
nathell 2 hours ago [-]
Anything that satisfies one’s intellectual curiosity is on-topic on HN. This is arguably _more_ on-topic than most slop.
You don't need a fancy glass. Your sense of smell makes a huge difference when it comes to food and drink, as anybody with a nasty cold can tell you. You want something that keeps it from diffusing into the air so anything with a wide mouth makes it harder to appreciate.
So: a cognac snifter; sherry glass; a glencairn, which was ""made for whisky""; etc.
But of course it's down to taste.
If the aroma is too heady? Blow air into glass and then inhale the aroma. The burn is gone (important if you're drinking 62% rocket fuel single cask whisky) and you get a more dilute smell.
No need for all this pretension; this glass is that.
Have you ever tasted red wine from a proper wine glass next to a regular cup and noticed how the wine hits a different part of your pallet? How the thickness of the glass affects the experience? How the size and shape affects the aroma?
These are real things, none of which you need.
You don’t need audiophile speakers to listen to music, but if you’re an audiophile or even anyone with good hearing, your experience is going to be different with better speakers.
You don’t need a fancy pizza oven to make good pizza, but you can make better pizza - at least of certain kinds - with one.
You can be a “serious whiskey collector” and not care about the glass, just like you can be a serious fan of music and not care about the speakers, or a serious hiker and not care about your attire, or serious golfer and not care about your clubs or balls, etc etc.
Maybe more applicable here, you can be a great software developer and write in PHP.
I drink whiskey and wine from whatever glass is in close reach, however when that happens to be a proper glass, I definitely notice.
So please don’t cast your disdain on people who care about the nuances of their experience, no matter how nice your whiskey collection is.
The rest of your argumentation are points I've never made, and many (aside from the audiophile one, which is mostly bunkum) like that wood-fired pizza oven is better is of course true in abstract for bread and pizza making.
But doing this makes the drink weaker so he set out to make a glass that gives you the best of both worlds. He even went around the US to distilleries and masters of bourbons and they could tell the difference.
He also said he’s not trying to sell this to the places he visited. He thinks that restaurants could start offering different whiskey glasses akin to how they do with wine down the line.
When you're next in Scotland, check the weather forecast. Look for a period of gentle <5mph wind pushing the evaporated whiskey from the distillery and bond houses into some trees or hills nearby. Scotland is usually quite a windy place so you'll need to time it. If you're in the central belt, Dumgoyne distillery has this often when you start the walk up the hill behind it. I've also experienced this walking in the forest immediately behind the Ben Nevis distillery. No need for fancy glasses... just go and enjoy the open air experience!
Pedantic note: Dumgoyne is the hill behind the distillery; the distillery itself is Glengoyne.
I did really get the impression that serious whiskey drinkers do not care for pretension.
I wouldn't buy one of these, but I understand why others would.
An interesting deep dive would be when this came about with humans, was there "mead with notes of huckleberry" in medieval times or did it start farther back in history? When did this concept originate? Is it called by different names in different cultures?
> a cognac snifter ... a glencairn
I think it's all relative.
Like audiophile cables, the placebo effect contributes to the experience. Or maybe it’s the lack of nocebo that helps. Either way, someone convinced the whiskey tastes better from that glass will actually taste something better in their subjective experience.
[0]. https://theneatglass.com/product/the-artisan-neat-glass-2-pa...
Glug, glug, glug, glug.
Source: Snuffy Smith, Jed Clampett, Pogo
https://norlanglass.com/products/norlan-whisky-glass
Now, I haven't owned one of these for years, because my wife put both of mine in the dishwasher and broke them. $32 for one glass is too much for me to stomach given my middling level of interest in whiskey these days, and a rocks glass is good enough. But they were damn fine glasses. Someday when I'm rich and famous, I'll buy some more.
https://www.ikea.com/us/en/p/ivrig-glass-clear-glass-5025832...
Those are quite nice, though they do lack the distinctive inner shape of the Glencairn / Norlan. But I bet they're more than sufficient for directing some whiskey smells to your nose and at a 10th of the price, it's hard to get too uppity about the subtle difference.
Nice shout!
Norlan is double-walled in order to keep let the drinker sip their whisky without it warming up. A lot of people drink their whisky cold, both because it softens the attack and also because it changes the taste a bit, and whisky drinking is all about drinking the same thing over and over again and discovering new things each time.
As a side note Norlan glasses are borosilicate and therefore perfectly appropriate for hot beverages. I suspect they might actually be some of the best tea tasting glasses available although I haven't tried it out yet.
The Norlan glass I linked above is actually thinner walled - the "chunkiness" just comes from the double-wall. (And I'd be happier to buy a new set if the glass was thicker, which would have saved my aforementioned set from being killed by ... water, in the dishwasher).
I think the reasons for his choices are overblown and the glass looks ugly.
https://savuglass.com/
Created by Finnish molecular chemistry PhDs. The shape looks like it too (an industrial designer would never approve this asymmetric lumpiness). But it does make a tangible difference.
Looks absolutely amazing with clear drinks on the rocks (duh).
[1] https://patents.google.com/patent/US2905350A/en
[2] https://archive.org/details/conex-containers-1968/page/n11/m...
There are definitely real advantages to the design. I’m especially fond of the flared lip; it avoids agitating the beer and making it aggressively bubble as you sip.
But there are of course competitors and alternatives to the Teku, including from Rastal themselves. I purchased a set of Craft Master One tumblers: https://rastal.com/en/product-search/craft-master-one-tumble...
All this to say, this article isn’t entirely bullshit. But if Zalto is truly successful, there will be plenty of clones vying to replace the standard snifter.
https://bladerunnerglass.com/
They are massive.. chunky to hold... wide mouthed... basically all the things that people in the article and here are saying are negative features for a whiskey glass...
And yet they are my favorite pieces of glassware. Nothing even comes close; I bring them out for special occasions and it always just feels.. special.. to drink from one.
I dunno, is it just the nostalgia for the film? Would I think the same thing if I had never seen Blade Runner before and someone just gave me the glass? Maybe, maybe not. Doesn't matter. Absolutely love the things.
Meanwhile other, much less harmful drugs (THC, psylocibin) are shunned, judged, even illegal.
There is so much hypocrisy and double standards in our rules that one wonders if we are a rational species at all.
I am not arguing against legalisation of weed but the weed they have now will really screw you up and psychedelics can push right into psychosis.
Nearly 200,000 people will die this year in the US alone as a result of alcohol. Want to take a guess at expected THC and Psilocybin deaths?
nicotine - cigarettes
to some extent, dopamine - chocolate
my great-grandparents could even buy cocaine in a drugstore in their time
Guess addictions aren't problematic as long as they do not affect productivity.
In any case, if that were the only concern, then I claim you would likely not see the legalizing or loosening of restrictions. On the contrary, I claim that this growing laxity is at least subconsciously if not explicitly motivated by a fear of growing discontent over our oligarchic political order, and the desire to “neutralize” the nasty effects of the disordered lifestyles it encourages and to render people docile.
https://us.josephinen.com/collections/josephine-whisky-glass...
Stemless dramatically changes the profile of the drink since now your hand is warming it (hence why chilled wines are always served in stem glasses).
Sure, things like a wide glass vs a testtube would make a (probably small) difference but beyond gross differences, I struggle to take these sorts of conversations seriously.
So in other words, not optimised for actual scotch whisky.
Also, 1 out of 5 images/videos were provided by the company itself, the other 4 credit people who work for or at the NYT.
If you want that combination of lifestyle topics and serious journalism, the NYT Magazine is a better place to find it. E.g. this article about FIRE: https://www.nytimes.com/2024/05/07/magazine/retire-early-sav...
And notice the very long, thin stem in the picture? That'll maximize breakage, so your customers need to keep buying more glasses.
- Medical treatment is a universal essential for life & health. Whiskey glassware is a niche luxury purchase.
- Creating a pretty-effective whiskey glass can be done, reliably, on a small budget. Vs. creating a pretty-effective medical treatment, and getting the approvals needed to sell it as such? Yeah.
- Medical treatment has a huge conventional medicine establishment - which is notorious for being unable to provide effective treatment for patients with many sorts of chronic problems. And is all too often contemptuously dismissive of their complaints. Which gives alternative medicine a huge pipeline of prospective customers, and the immediate cheap win of just taking their complaints seriously.
https://web.archive.org/web/20170315204955/https://www.machi...
fruit has huge differences in taste depending on the specific variety, where it’s grown, how long ago it was picked, especially stuff like stone fruit or berries. meat, fish, etc also have huge differences in quality and taste.
but maybe i just haven’t had the right glassware :)
1. Do what makes you happy.
2. Don't make other people feel bad for not being as discerning/picky as you about something.
3. Becoming more discerning about something may make you happy at times, but it may also cost you money and turn a simple pleasure into an unsatisfying pursuit. Choose your obsessions carefully! You can choose not to care.
You probably have friends who, by your standards, are shamefully oblivious to the quality of fruit they eat. If they're happy don't spoil it for them.
The stuff aficionados do does tend to make a difference up to a point. It's not all BS. However, there is typically a diminishing returns curve. Often, there is also some self-deception or outright snake-oil further up the curve.
The only argument I'd make for getting picky about whisky is that you can enjoy the equivalent of a shot for an hour or more. Not as pretense. I mean genuinely enjoying the smell of it for that long and slowly sipping it. It's a way to drink without drinking much. My experience is that glasses do make a difference, but only if you like whisky on its own (or with a few drops of water) at room temperature. If you prefer cocktails or whisky on the rocks, whisky-specific glasses are probably something you don't need to worry about.
Remember recommendations #1 and #3 before you go any further! If you're happy, stay happy! It's okay to choose not to care about whisky. If you can choose not to drink alcohol at all you're probably better off.
alcohol is usually a far better solvent than water for the compounds providing those nuances. if you want to enjoy those flavors out of situ, hello alcohol
Even compared to beer it's just not that interesting. It felt a bit culty at times, to be honest. But then there's the fact that most people get drunk off the stuff. I stopped doing most drugs before I hit 30. Alcohol was the first to go, being the most boring with the worst side effects. Once you get rid of that there's not a lot left really.
> donuts especially are amazing less minutes after frying!
Oh, absolutely! They are probably my favourite baked item, but I won't even bother unless I can actually see the dough so into the fryer. Unfortunately it's incredibly rare to find a good one. Most are loaded with sugary nonsense to compensate for them not being fresh. Interestingly, in the UK, a country known for obesity, foods like doughnuts where you can see frying process are properly out of fashion. But in nearby Spain, a much thinner country, they have no problem with churros and tortillas etc. It's a shame because doughnuts are far superior.