Rendered at 17:07:09 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Cloudflare Workers.
bityard 2 days ago [-]
Adjacent to this, my life got immeasurably better when I stopped trying to prove myself to everyone. I always tried to share my ideas and opinions in every meeting. I was obsessed with trying to "read" people to figure out their unspoken priorities, what made them tick, trying to predict what they would say and do next, and match my actions to elicit their approval.
What a huge goddamn waste of time that was.
It got to a point that to preserve my sanity at work, I kept my head down, did the work that needed to be done (whether assigned or not), stopped going to meetings I didn't care about, and stayed mostly silent in all others. All the while dreaming of a new career or early retirement. But then a strange thing happened... It turns out that if your reputation is one of quiet confidence, people start to actually listen. They assume that when you do talk, it's only going to be about something important and worth hearing. Instead of co-workers on other teams trying to throw their work over the wall at you, they begin every innocent question with an apology: "hey, I know you're super busy, but I was wondering if I could bug you real quick..." Borderline indifference is so far my favorite superpower that I've accidentally discovered.
rr808 2 days ago [-]
I've done this my whole career. I'm happy doing whatever is in my bubble. Its really hard to get promoted though, you need skip level managers to hear about you and you need to sell yourself and your work upstairs.
pjmlp 45 minutes ago [-]
As someone that also shares the same traits, most times the promotion isn't really that great, especially in companies where the only way up is management.
Been there once and don't feel like repeating it.
enoint 7 hours ago [-]
Yeah, I wonder if there are any HR or managers on this thread who can detect grey rock, instead of labeling the person “disengaged”
safety1st 2 days ago [-]
I don't really like the grey rocking idea, I think it has its place, the article covers this, there are a few true psychopaths out there where the best strategy is to totally disengage but if you can't do that the next best thing is to grey rock around them.
But beyond that I wouldn't use it, I think it creates a boring and stagnant life. What I think is better is to have a few "north stars" and pick your battles. Only pick the fights which bring you closer to your north star and which you have a good shot at winning. Go ahead and pick those with reckless abandon, and when you run out of them you really do just get to turn off, go home, watch some TV, maybe meditate on where you might find more of those battles, but otherwise ignore anything and everyone you feel like ignoring.
This will create a way more interesting and fruitful life than a general policy of being boring in order to be ignored. This is how you carve out a life which is exactly what you want to live, instead of living in reaction to others. Just be smart about when you stick your neck out or spend your energy and attention. Especially in the modern era where attention is the most valuable resource in existence.
In my experience this is way more likely to just get you ignored, I'm somewhat surprised of your experience as it doesn't match mine. I used to keep my head down and it was a quick road to towards being ignored. The only thing that helped me is to speak up and engage.
It could be different cultures though, I'm from west EU.
bityard 5 hours ago [-]
Being ignored (most of the time) is the whole idea!
The nice thing about this philosophy is that you actually have the time to dig deep into interesting problems because your aren't constantly reacting to other people's demands and deadlines.
One caveat is that you need to have a great manager who understands this work ethic and its benefits.
747-8I 2 days ago [-]
Yes, similar experience.
ryandrake 2 days ago [-]
I think this is something you can/should do when you get to where you want to be in your career. If you do it from day one, you'll stay junior for your whole life. Put on your Hustle Face, be the life of the party, get involved with workplace drama, and make those stupid "ambition noises" for the first N years of your career, until you get to the point where you're making "enough" and have some job security, and then Grey Rock until FIRE or retirement.
I don't get these people who just stay Type A HustleBros their entire careers. Like, where are you going, man, and what are you really hoping to get? At some point $SALARY X 1.1 is just not worth the mental toil.
ct520 2 days ago [-]
Same experience
intellectronica 2 days ago [-]
From experience: it works, and can be an effective tactic when no other options are available.
Long-term, it can be hard to sustain, and maybe a bit unhealthy – it becomes a form of self-betrayal, where you repeatedly suppress genuine negative feelings about dealing with someone difficult. These feelings are there for a reason, even if expressing them with the person triggering them would be counterproductive.
Also, in more extreme cases, the sort of people who are prone to creating drama and conflict pick up on the technique and make it into a battle of wills – who will break and give up first. And they may be a lot better at it than you are, because for them it is a central feature of their personality, and for you it's just a tactic for immediate relief.
akudha 2 days ago [-]
One of the smartest engineers I worked with ever, used to say "you always have a choice to not get involved". He was older than me (at least a decade) - I didn't understand him at the time, not sure I understand him fully today after all these years.
But he's got a point. Lots of time, we do have a choice. This is especially true online. We know someone is saying/doing crazy things just to get attention, but we still engage, especially when it comes to topics like politics and religion. At that point, I suppose it is more of our fault.
That said, this is unlikely to fully work with colleagues, family, friends. So maybe the always part is not true?
This is all easy in theory, but the difficulty comes in having the discipline to practice...
CoolestBeans 2 days ago [-]
Well said. In essence grey rocking itself is a form of defensive manipulation. Most of us are prosocial and find it really laborious to keep up. It's an ok tactic when communication is ineffective or harmful. It is probably a bad idea to use it with someone you simply have a point of friction with. It can be hard to know the difference sometimes though.
justonceokay 2 days ago [-]
Maybe, but not all of us really need to do this. It seems to me that “gray rocking“ is a corrective strategy for the type of person who easily overreacts.
Put another way, the type of person who is naturally “boring” and not very reactive probably won’t get themselves tangled with the kind of person that needs to be “grey rocked”. If you are always a gray rock, then you are not an easy target for a manipulator.
sanarothe 2 days ago [-]
Hm
Grey rocking has one definition, or use I guess, when one is in an abusive living situation, this is maladaptive strategy to just.. kinda.. curl up on not a ball, take your metaphorical or physical kicks, and let the aggressor just kinda... Get bored.
SilverElfin 2 days ago [-]
Manipulation is right. It can also be used as an offensive manipulation. In relationships, grey rocking can be a punitive form of emotional abuse. Adjacent to silent treatment or stonewalling. Sometimes people may justify it to themselves as a tactic for when communication is ineffective, but more often than not, it’s avoiding the type of communication that’s needed in healthy relationships.
whoanoway 2 days ago [-]
[dead]
verisimi 2 days ago [-]
> In essence grey rocking itself is a form of defensive manipulation.
Maybe it is defensive but it can also be aggressive. For situations where time is on their side, it can really just be a means of handling the situation - there is no reason to think it is only a defence against aggressors. It is ultimately just a manipulation technique.
Perhaps it's a stretch, but I think the policy that Google has in place, where they are notoriously hard to get a response from, is an example of aggressive grey rocking. They have no interest in hearing your possibly justified complaint - if they make it impossible for you to speak, you have no ability to seek redress. Endless complaint procedures are the same thing. Being put on hold for hours also.
atoav 2 days ago [-]
I knew a person who constantly grayrocked even people she has never met before who she totally could have been open with. Just like any method you can use or abuse it.
If you find yourself in the blast radius of an abusive narcissistic person for example, grayrocking is totally a decent way to deal with them, while keeping your calm. But using it towards everybody whom you're not 100% on board with is probably a bit overkill.
anaisbetts 1 days ago [-]
Yep, this is a tactic to use with people who cannot be reasoned with, and is usually discussed in the context of emotionally abusive people (i.e. relatives with NPD) because there are no other viable options. It's not a healthy way to deal with everyone in your life
2 days ago [-]
euroderf 1 days ago [-]
I used to be infinitely patient with people and infinitely impatient with objects. But I think I had it backwards.
sublinear 2 days ago [-]
> Long-term, it can be hard to sustain, and maybe a bit unhealthy – it becomes a form of self-betrayal, where you repeatedly suppress genuine negative feelings about dealing with someone difficult.
It is unhealthy simply because it's a rebranded form of passive aggression. The real problem is not yet having figured out why someone like that can get under your skin in the first place.
The exact same situations that can bubble up unhealthy amounts of negative emotion in younger people don't do that in older people. Older people have already been there and done that. They fully understand the behavior and instead of anger or retaliation they usually feel pity or nothing at all. Which mind do you think is healthier?
In other words, there's no escaping life's lessons. Your best bet is to minimize the unavoidable consequences and stay out of trouble. For sure, a big part of that is cutting out bullshit like Esquire. This "grey rocking" stuff is just woo woo nonsense that was meant to prime you for ads that already happened back in 2021.
jancsika 2 days ago [-]
> Your best bet is to minimize the unavoidable consequences and stay out of trouble.
That's the exact definition of "grey rocking." It's a harm minimization technique taught to victims of narcissists who are unable to immediately get away from the narcissist. Examples would be people who must stay in contact because of kids, or someone planning an escape over the course of weeks/months.
I know someone personally in the latter category. "Grey rocking" for the week prior to their escape was indeed "their best bet" and definitely not "woo woo."
sublinear 2 days ago [-]
The "woo woo" part is that people are talking about it like it's cognitive behavioral therapy for assholes. Then we've gone and made a buzzword so people will respond to ads.
It's nonsense.
gleeker 2 days ago [-]
Huh, I guess so!
nye2k 2 days ago [-]
I like the idea of a Yellow Rock, still shining, smiling and being the positive old self, just giving absolutely nothing in return for toxic behavior... In my situation, morale improved across the department and the mental beatings came to an end.
Grey Rock method worked against a particularly toxic work conflict that was keeping me awake at night... but... the reality was that it produced zero work results for any of us.
xyzsparetimexyz 23 hours ago [-]
The only yellow rock I can think of is sulfur.
raajg 18 hours ago [-]
Can’t stop laughing :D
syradar 11 hours ago [-]
Yellow Cake
al_borland 1 days ago [-]
I suppose I have been doing something akin to this for 30+ years now... a defense mechanism I developed in adolescence.
I don't know that I'd recommend it. It started as a means to get people to leave me alone, but at some point, it just became who I am. I struggle to get excited about anything or to express strong opinions about things. This makes life very flat. For someone who is living with a bunch of drama, they may look at my life and see it as peaceful, but it is also really mundane. I worry I will get to the end of my life, look back, and realize that I never really lived. But at this point, I've been this way for so long that it's all I really know. I have vague memories as a child of not being like this, but I don't see a path back as an adult.
Proceed with extreme caution.
avidiax 1 days ago [-]
My suspicion, as someone that has anhedonia and dysthymia myself, is that there are a couple of nuances to your situation.
First, is that grey rocking is a tactical choice, an act. If you've done this since adolescence, it suggests that this is a learned defense mechanism, not a tactical choice. Someone that is truly "grey rocking" has some kind of relatively lively personality that they are suppressing as a tactic. This doesn't sound like what you've described for yourself. That's not to say that you don't have some lively personality in waiting: we all were rambunctious or curious children, and somewhere inside all of us, that child lives.
Second, I would suspect that you grew up in an environment where having needs, showing excitement, or expressing strong opinions drew attack, mockery, or drama. Thus, being boring and expressing no opinions or emotions was a quite valid adaptation to the environment, which persists into adulthood.
The unfortunate trick is that you usually won't start doing various activities that make healthy people happy (socializing and hobbies) and experience the same happiness and joy. The early phase will be that you feel some curiosity, attention or engagement, and perhaps anger and annoyance at the friction in any new or long disregarded experience.
Feeling something is the first step.
al_borland 1 days ago [-]
I do remember making the conscious choice to act this way, due to the environment you mention. I figured I just had to do it until college, when I'd be on my own. But when doing something long enough, eventually it just sticks, especially if it's early in life. That transition period was stifled by the act I was putting on, so the potential adult version of who I was never formed, it was created while acting.
For someone who is already an established adult, it may be a different story, especially if it's just for a few months and around one person who has the ability to leave.
I am trying to work on it now, after 20 years of using alcohol as a crutch to feel things and participate socially, which killed all my other hobbies and the social participation over time.
The warning is more for younger readers or those who would need to employ this for years on end, especially through big life transitions. Be careful not to lose yourself in the role.
AnthonBerg 1 days ago [-]
I've been climbing out of the same state after… long story; Fiancée was nearly dead from a badly missed Type 1 diabetes diagnosis. She was severely ill for years, the full last year so gravely sick that most people would have died. She was out of her mind. (Her brain shut off entire non-critical sections like the frontal lobe so those would still be there when she got back. It's marvelous. And horrifying.) I had to assume an impeccable bedside manner. Grey rocking someone's severe illness can mess you up bad.
As far as I understand it, part of how we suppress emotion is that we stop reacting to it, and we stop breathing in accordance with requirements for proper functioning of emotion and emotional reaction. We get lost inside it.
greyr0ck 2 days ago [-]
Grey rock is a very valuable technique, but also often a symptom of having low boundaries yourself. It can be exciting to have the attention of a grandiose person at first, but having people you can't say no to is a huge problem.
She is amazing. I particularly recommend the older "glossary" videos.
david-gpu 2 days ago [-]
I find Ramani to be rather contemptuous of or bitter about people she doesn't like. In other words, to me she comes across as somewhat hypocritical.
If you enjoy Ramani, you may also want to read the works of Dr. Lindsay Gibson. She does a great job of guiding people who suffer from having emotionally immature parents, without dehumanizing them. She doesn't even use clinical terms in her books, even though she is a clinical psychologist. The principles are the same even if the people you are struggling with are not your parents.
deepfriedchokes 2 days ago [-]
Therapists can get burned out, especially those who work with NPD people, and Ramani seems over it. Unfortunately that comprises her usefulness as a therapist and as a source of expert advice. Dr. Mark Ettensohn of the YouTube channel Heal NPD is a better source, imo.
Ramani specializes in NPD. People with NPD are not able to provide for themselves emotionally so they rely on others, their “narcissist supply”, to which they become dependent. It’s very much like addiction, except instead of abusing a substance, they end up abusing people in order to meet their needs; people become objects and resources instead of being people. That objectification, if not treated, is how narcissism spreads. That’s the great benefit of grey rocking; they aren’t attracted to people who don’t give them energy and will leave them alone. Yellow rocking is a more positive way to interact with the world, but you have to be really good at setting boundaries, otherwise someone with NPD will misjudge polite engagement as a willingness to give them energy. With NPD people, imho it’s more kind to grey rock, as yellow rocking can make them feel rejected, which adds to their trauma. Like addiction, the thing that helps them recover is to be cut off from their supply, so they can learn to provide for their own emotional needs instead of relying on external sources. Very often empathetic people unintentionally end up acting as enablers which causes more harm. Objectification harms the objectifier as well as the person being objectified; if they see others as objects, they internalize that themselves as well, and become the source of their own trauma.
david-gpu 2 days ago [-]
> Dr. Mark Ettensohn of the YouTube channel Heal NPD is a better source, imo.
Thanks for the tip, I will check him out.
I will admit that these days I do not consume any material that deals with NPD, because while I found it useful early on to contextualize the behavior of a couple of people who have abused me, it is not my responsibility to either diagnose or treat them. Instead, my attention has shifted to folks like Tim Fletcher and Lindsay Gibson, who elaborate on the path to recovery.
> Like addiction, the thing that helps them recover is to be cut off from their supply
There appears to be quite some debate around whether or not folks with NPD can be treated at all, with only a few therapists seemingly confident that they can genuinely help them, such as Diana Diamond et al.
graemep 1 days ago [-]
I think Ramani is useful for people in the midst of dealing with people with narcissistic traits, especially if they cannot immediately escape the relationship. There are probably others who are better at understanding from a greater distance.
wasmperson 21 hours ago [-]
There was a video released about 2 years ago documenting these kinds of "how to deal with a narcissist" content creators. Both the mental health blog referenced in the article and the channel you linked seem to be from that sphere. As a rule you should be hesitant to assign these kinds of labels to people.
This is pseudoscientific drivel btw. If you want to learn about people, go interact with more people, don't fall into this analytical rabbithole of labels, disorders, personality categories, flowcharts for what to say to X if they do Y, etc. This is not only inefficient for achieving your own goals, it's also gonna make you into a weird human being and a pain in the ass to deal with.
graemep 1 days ago [-]
It is an extremely useful technique for someone suffering abuse at the hands of a particular type of person.
I do not know where you got the idea of flowcharts. No one mentioned them.
The article takes it too far by treating it as a technique for dealing with difficult situations with normal people. However, the comment you responded to recommends Dr Ramani, who promotes it as a technique for dealing with narcissistic abusers. She also says in one video that its not the diagnosis that matters, it the behaviour that you have to deal with. Do you have a better suggestions for that situation?
Why should anyone care if an abuser finds them a weird human being? Your aim is usually to get away from the relationship, what serves that better than grey rock?
glerk 23 hours ago [-]
> However, the comment you responded to recommends Dr [sic] Ramani
Yes, this is what I am addressing. I clicked and skimmed that YouTube channel and I've seen this type of content recommended before. It is precisely the analytical rabbithole of personality types and flowcharts I was referring to. You are proving my point by using the label "narcissistic abuser".
> Do you have a better suggestions for that situation?
If you judge that interacting with someone is harmful to you, I suggest you simply stop interacting with them. If you are dealing with actual abuse (i.e. unwanted communication after you've expressed your desire to stop communicating, stalking, threats, etc.), there are usually legal steps you can take depending on your jurisdiction.
graemep 23 hours ago [-]
> Dr [sic] Ramani
Why did you insert the [sic]? Do you mean I should properly call her Dr Durvasula? That is pedantic and impedes communication.
> you are proving my point by using the label "narcissistic abuser".
Which part of it do you object to?
Are you saying people should not be labelled abusers? If so, I very strongly disagree.
Are you saying people should not be labelled "narcissistic"? There is an identifiable pattern of behaviour, and techniques for dealing with it. it is useful. I have found it much easier to deal with someone once I dealt with narcissistic behaviour as such, using techniques such as grey rock.
> If you judge that interacting with someone is harmful to you, I suggest you simply stop interacting with them.
Nice simple solution for some! What if you are married to them and living in the same house? There are financial constraints to just moving out. You may have children you need to protect which you cannot do if you leave, unless you take the children with you which itself can be a problem - and that means you have to be sure the courts will take your side if the abuser contests who should have the children.
Even worse, what if the abuser is a parent and you are still a minor? Just stop interacting with someone you are dependant on?
The core of domestic abuse is control and manipulation. Undermining people's self confidence, controlling them financially, or with threats to them and others. Apart from the practical constraints you are doing the equivalent of telling someone with depression to "snap out of it", or someone with PTSD to "man up", etc.
> If you are dealing with actual abuse
You really do not seem to understand the nature of abuse.
> here are usually legal steps you can take depending on your jurisdiction.
For some things, not others. It has to be something that is 1) illegal and 2) something the police and the courts are interested in enforcing.
My experience is that although coercive control is a crime in the UK, the police (and courts) are not interested unless there is evidence of violence, nor in male victims (who also almost always do not have the option of fleeing to a shelter). I have actually been told by the police that they were not interested in even looking at evidence.
glerk 22 hours ago [-]
> Why did you insert the [sic]?
From the information I could find, this person has a PhD in psychology, which I deem to be a pseudoscience. Her usage of "Dr" is meant to project an image of authority: most people associate "Doctor" with "medical doctor" i.e. someone qualified to diagnose diseases and prescribe treatments. This person is not a doctor in that sense. She is a counselor/therapist who runs a YouTube channel.
> Are you saying people should not be labelled abusers?
> Are you saying people should not be labelled "narcissistic"?
Yes. I'm very skeptical that labeling people and putting them in these boxes is helpful. It's just horoscopes with the veneer of science. In my experience, almost everyone can display traits that are associated with "narcissism" to various degrees depending on the context (egoism, feeling superior to others, envy, callousness, etc.). And this goes for other "personality types" these psychologists use as a diagnosis. These categories are fuzzy, unstable over time, and often overlapping (is this person a narcissist, a sociopath, or antisocial? Or are they just having a bad day?). Overall, I don't think this ontological zoo of personality types and disorders is very helpful.
> Nice simple solution for some! What if you are married to them and living in the same house? There are financial constraints to just moving out [...] what if the abuser is a parent and you are still a minor?
Depending on the specific situation you are facing, there are procedures for that, such as divorce courts or child protective services. It seems to me that you are seeking some way to indirectly manipulate a person you deem an abuser into behaving in the way you want and you are doing this by guessing how they would behave based on these personality types. Imo, this is weird and inefficient. If communicating your needs directly to the person in question doesn't work, I would seek a more direct route for ending these relationships you deem abusive.
> You really do not seem to understand the nature of abuse
Maybe I don't, no. If you can share, what specifically are you talking about?
graemep 7 hours ago [-]
I disagree about the title Dr. Most people are quite used to its use as an academic title (which is older than its use as a medical one). Anyone who has gone to university will have have been taught by many people with doctorates. It is a common basis for jokes in things like sitcoms (which only work if the audience understand the difference). I know more people with PhDs socially than medical doctors.
Many of the most dubious theories in the area have been devised by psychiatrists who are medical doctors.
So you would never label anyone an abuser? What is someone beats their spouse if they do not do what they are told?
If so, why exclude someone who achieves the same objective through other means? Control of finances, control of children, lies, social isolation, constant yelling and put downs....?
> In my experience, almost everyone can display traits that are associated with "narcissism" to various degrees depending on the context (egoism, feeling superior to others, envy, callousness, etc.). And this goes for other "personality types" these psychologists use as a diagnosis. These categories are fuzzy, unstable over time, and often overlapping (is this person a narcissist, a sociopath, or antisocial? Or are they just having a bad day?).
Yes, there are blurry boundaries, but what I think you do not understand is just how extreme these people are. We all have bad traits, but for most people these are not the dominant elements in our personalities. We are talking about people who are self-centred, manipulative, deceitful, and controlling very extremely and consistently. People who will scream and yell every day, lie to others to make people look bad, use friends and family to put pressure on their spouse (including telling them they are bad), tell they are children they are wicked and stupid daily, and even publicly, do things (real specific example!) like unplug an internet connection to stop their spouse taking part in a zoom call with their family.
Dr Ramani actually addresses the issue of exact labels. She says in one video that a diagnosis does not matter. If you are faced with that sort of behaviour then you use the appropriate ways of dealing with it.
> Depending on the specific situation you are facing, there are procedures for that, such as divorce courts or child protective services.
Do you expect children to be able to ask those services to intervene? I have already pointed out the practical problems with divorce. Divorce and moving out takes time and people have limited options. You grey rock in the meantime. It took me well over an year (and a lot of effort dealing with the courts) from telling my ex-wife I was divorcing her to her actually moving out. Techniques like grey rock help you understand that.
> I would seek a more direct route for ending these relationships you deem abusive.
There are multiple problems with that. Firstly you need to identify the relationship as abusive. We are talking about people who are manipulative and deceitful. The labels help people realise that these people will never change, and how to deal with them. You also need to be able to go through things like the divorce process.
Society discourages people (especially men) from recognising that they are victims of abuse. There are huge pressures to keep a relationship going. People put up with a lot if they think its best for their children. You can face social pressure to keep a relationship going. A lot of people will just brush aside the issue.
I think another thing you underestimate is how years of manipulation and undermining affects people's self confidence and ability to function normally.
Jdfmiller 2 days ago [-]
I had a difficult family member who used to give drama, telling intense and fantastical stories. My go to word just became a simple ‘Yikes’ and then silence.
After a while they tended not to talk to me at family functions.
I use it when dealing with over-sharers or people who are after a reaction and attention.
ulrikrasmussen 1 days ago [-]
At least the article is honest about this technique being a bit of a nuclear option rather than this one cool trick to remove drama from your life. In essence, the technique tells you to suppress your own personality in your interactions with other people to not feed THEIR psychological flaws. If you do this to people who you actually want to keep in your life, I think you'll find that they'll eventually stop inviting you to things.
I don't know. Sure, if being stalked by your ex is making your life a living hell, maybe this is a better alternative. But I couldn't imagine living like this long term, and I know that I would also lose contact to a friend if they chose to just erase their own personality like that.
AngryData 2 days ago [-]
Not sure I like how this is framed. If you don't like someone or what they do, ignore them and what they say, don't engage, it is as simple as that. You don't need some special "grey rock" technique or change who you are or present as anything else. Someone is a piece of shit to you? Don't change yourself to be boring, just don't interact with that person. That is as "boring" as it gets.
neilk 2 days ago [-]
I’ve seen this work spectacularly well for a journalist who was being hounded online by a mob. The journalist just made the most insipid and boring posts for almost a year. Like talking about how great a glass of water was. The mob moved on.
Mikhail_Edoshin 1 days ago [-]
A man changes into a grey rock and finds certain areas of his life have improved. But then he attributes the improvement to the magic properties of grey rocks.
But what if grey rocks are not that special? Could it be that a change into anything would bring some degree of improvement? Maybe the actual driver is to change yourself instead of waiting for the world to change? If so, maybe there are better things than grey rocks?
(I myself like Harvey in "Harvey".)
jayd16 2 days ago [-]
Doesn't this just lead to being steamrolled on every decision or would be conflict? Seems like it would work if the person is addicted to drama but not if they're happy to simply use you.
To me it seems like the crux of the technique is "don't engage in drama" but making yourself lesser to do that seems problematic.
bityard 2 days ago [-]
I believe the goal of gray-rocking here is to defend yourself against overly dramatic and abusive bullies which you are forced to have some minimal contact with (family member, co-worker on another team, friend-of-a-friend), not someone you have to deal and negotiate with daily. Those require different and situation-dependent strategies.
It's not making yourself lesser, it's basically "not taking the bait," which is very much a strength, not a weakness.
overfeed 2 days ago [-]
> To me it seems like the crux of the technique is "don't engage in drama" but making yourself lesser to do that seems problematic.
Grey rocking is variant of the old message board adage about not feeding trolls, the defenders don't lessen themselves, but reduce the opportunity for abuse.
exegete 2 days ago [-]
I think it depends on the power dynamic. It’s probably easier to implement with family members outside of your home than your manager.
63 2 days ago [-]
I've found this helpful for getting along with family who I know wouldn't like certain aspects of my life but for whom going no-contact is more trouble than it's worth.
"How's your job?"
"About the same. Still just working with computers."
"Any girls in your life?"
"Nah not really. Hard to meet people these days."
"What kind of music do you listen to?"
"Whatever they play on the radio I guess"
"You go to church?"
"When I can"
"Who are you voting for?"
"I haven't thought about it too much. Who are you voting for?"
Answer the question but reveal nothing and they have nothing to pry at. Worst case, turn it around and let them talk about themselves for awhile. Throw in a "Uh huh," "Oh man," and "I'd never thought about it like that" every few minutes until it's time to go.
antisthenes 2 days ago [-]
What you're doing isn't really grey rocking, it's just a normal conversation between 2 people who aren't very close (like a coworker you speak to once a month) and frankly don't care too much.
tracerbulletx 2 days ago [-]
I don't really get this framing. You can not engage with drama and also not be boring or use this label. So maybe just do that?
bityard 2 days ago [-]
Yeah, I would just call it, "don't take the bait." But I guess giving this a label helps some people internalize it as a technique they can deliberately practice. Which isn't really a bad thing.
iberator 2 days ago [-]
You just don't get it.
For some people it needs to be extremely forced as its 100% against their nature and internal 'clock'.
It's like force walking when you have been a runner for a decade.
Imagine being forcibly downshifted into lets say working at PizzaHut as it's the only job you can get despite your IT career etc etc.
In order to avoid conflict, shame, drama you learn to just STFU and not reveal nothing personal to protect your sanity and privacy - even when some youngster in the kitchen bragging that he is the king of hackers, or when your boss is talking extreme nonsense that normally would you correct on the spot...
It's like literally being a fucking superman and you NEED to let someone die on your eyes just to keep your cover.
Edit: Oh lol. I guess you just have to click the captcha. Never seen that in an archive before.
Brian_K_White 2 days ago [-]
archive.is/ph/today/etc has been doing that for a long time
Though it might possibly vary depending where you come from, using cloudflare for dns, what browser plugins in effect, etc.
iloveyoutwo 1 days ago [-]
Being from Finland..
doright 2 days ago [-]
I ended up doing this for too long, thinking it would improve my situation. It only gave me an excuse to continue giving away my time and energy to being around people whose mere existence triggered me, and on top of that saying or doing anything to stand up for myself would then aggravate the situation. No contact was the only thing I could have done to save myself.
In hindsight, I understand this is a technique for when escape isn't possible. When you're still in the stage of blaming yourself and them alternately, suppressing your true feelings leads to feeling like you've abandoned yourself and there's nobody safe to talk to. In a sense, it's kind of what some narcissts want you to do - to become meek and obedient, feeling that any criticism you can say to them is undeserved.
imglorp 2 days ago [-]
If I understand this correctly, it means to modify your behavior to avoid unwanted reactions from others. Some call this walking on eggshells and it also means you have pressure to not be yourself.
2 days ago [-]
some_furry 2 days ago [-]
You did not, in fact, understand correctly.
It's masking your feelings, behaviors, and especially reactions to be as flat, boring, and neutral as possible. Your mission is to be unremarkable, so they leave you alone.
Walking on eggshells is more of an anxious behavior.
piloto_ciego 2 days ago [-]
Well, the problem is though, that masking ain't great for you either.
derwiki 2 days ago [-]
There’s a recent Hidden Brain about masking. Yes it’s often not great, but if you have some antisocial tendencies it can be beneficial to mask them.
some_furry 1 days ago [-]
Don't I know that, heh.
astura 2 days ago [-]
It's a tool to deal with high conflict, high drama people who you must interact with, to make interaction with them less harmful to you. Not a way to go through life in general.
tescreal 1 days ago [-]
For people who believe themselves to be sources of conflict, consider trying this. It forces you to listen more and react less. You will find your life improves somewhat, and when you have input, it will come to fewer uphill treks and more cordial outcomes. I realize most people jump on "surely it isn't me", and that's all fine and good, but it is worth entertaining the thought for your own benefit if you notice a pattern of conflict following you around.
beloch 2 days ago [-]
It's a valid tactic to use when bullied, but you need to be aware that this is what is happening and take other steps to stop it. Bullies will use any emotion you display against you. Happy about something? It's dumb and so are you. Sad about something? You're pathetic. Becoming an expressionless rock is a viable way to cut off that particular avenue of abuse, but they will likely find others.
If you find yourself doing this out of self-defence with someone, they're likely a bully and you should do your best to cut them out of your life. Rocks can still be pissed on. Another thing to be wary of is that, if you spend too much time grey rocking, you might become a rock to people who are kind to you.
Bottom line, if you need to "grey rock", you have a problem that might require a better solution.
Animats 2 days ago [-]
This is not a new idea. Here's the 1950s version, from the musical "How to Succeed In Business Without Really Trying".[1]
And what do I do if I am already really, really boring as heck?
__MatrixMan__ 2 days ago [-]
For those of us who are not harassed by people seeking drama... I guess we read a different article.
dofm 2 days ago [-]
Sit back and enjoy being in credit for once!
exegete 2 days ago [-]
Mission accomplished
conductr 23 hours ago [-]
As I read this article I couldn’t stop thinking how this woman author basically just learned how to be a man. Or, my version of “man” anyway, I’m sure it’s not universal but I feel like all this has always been my base level of how I live. I don’t like drama and do not engage with things and people that attract it.
yogurt-male 22 hours ago [-]
The byline says it was written by Tim Lewis, who appears to be a man.
lubujackson 2 days ago [-]
I worry this idea is being taken up as the next trend in our societal descent into antisocial avoidance.
Could it be useful if cornered by a predator at a bar, or a technique for dealing with racist grandma you can't otherwise engage with? I guess. But more likely this will be co-opted as an excuse for being unresponsive to their partners, friends, co-workers, etc., shutting down communication exactly when it is most impactful.
Be warned this is NOT a reasonable way to engage with the world. I dread a future where this is normalized into a real world form of ghosting, which is already a terrible trend turning everyone into avoidant turtles.
It is harmful to both parties - they don't know why you avoided them so they can't fix anything, and you lose assertiveness and the ability to handle any level of discomfort. And as a society we grow more and more disconnected until we simply stop breeding, like pandas.
dingdongditchme 2 days ago [-]
I'm glad that you said this. I am currently on the other side of behavior similar to this with a friend and it feels horrible. Its not the first time it has happened to me so I know i can cope, but I feel like a stalker for just reaching out. The worst I witnessed was my wife being ghosted by a very close friend of hers. It left us both rattled for a while and makes your head spin with theories all the while feeling sad. Can't recommend.
Yep avoidance is massively damaging to people around the person adopting these strategies. In attachment theory for example, avoidance is basically the most harmful way of participating in romantic relationships, and caused massive trauma for partners.
But I agreed, modern society seems to be normalizing these tactics. Instead of encouraging people to do the hard work of behaving in healthy ways.
Hnrobert42 2 days ago [-]
I think you are catastrophizing.
The article describes a technique for not engaging with "psychopaths and malignant narcissists." You worry that adoption of this technique will lead to the end of the human race.
enderforth 1 days ago [-]
I find the people most likely to call others "psychopaths and malignant narcissists" are most often the ones least likely to be qualified to make those diagnoses and most likely to abuse the label.
glitchc 2 days ago [-]
It's all fine until they do something that requires an action on your part to fix or correct. It is not a useful long-term strategy.
3pm 2 days ago [-]
If this article resonated - I highly recommend Bill Eddy and his books and podcasts. He does a good job on providing nomenclature - 4 or 5 cluster B personality disorders which he tones down to "high-conflict person" and patterns on dealing with them.
gherkinnn 1 days ago [-]
By all means behave like a grey rock when in an abusive relationship as described.
But as a modus operandi it sounds awful. The amount of people here yearning for a desert of grey rocks is disconcerting.
zecg 1 days ago [-]
> If your problems are more serious than the family WhatsApp, Skylar recommends that you turn your life into performance art for being boring.
You don't say
ataraxia937 2 days ago [-]
I can say from experience, years ago, that this doesn't work as a kid in school.
encody 2 days ago [-]
"Stoic"
"Sigma"
"Grey-rock"
vconnor 1 days ago [-]
Personally, I’d rather go nuclear, punch their nose, cut all contacts, move 500 km away and ignore their phone calls, than just going passive. I understand it works, I understand not everybody can leave right now, but grey rocking sounds like the behaviour of a hurt animal that has even lost the energy and will to live. It’s the ultimate tactic that requires self-annihilation. Get used to it too much, you find out one day you can’t get your personality back.
Life is too short to deal with assholes. Even if they’re your parents. Even if they’re the father/mother of your children. The world is vast.
bravoetch 2 days ago [-]
I would caution against this approach. It may be a band-aid to avoid interaction, but it won't replace good communication skills.
Doktor_IO 1 days ago [-]
It works. But in the way the article frames it, it distributed "psychopath" labels in a way that bothered me. All to often in relationships where the dynamics are broken, this word gets thrown around. I have been called a psychopath by a psychopath. But alongside the fact that [psychopathy is not exactly a well defined condition](https://theconversation.com/psychopathy-some-experts-now-say...), singling someone out as a psychopath has multiple negative consequences for all involved.
LoganDark 2 days ago [-]
I have a lot of experience with this, and it sucks. But it works. People will learn to stop expecting things out of you that don't happen. And once there's nothing left for them, they will lose interest completely.
jimmyjazz14 2 days ago [-]
Bless your heart, back home we call it southern hospitality.
avazhi 2 days ago [-]
Some prepubescent edgy Cosmo writer somehow got published in Esquire (alas just about everybody’s standards have slipped), so good for her - but it’s impossible to get through this type of writing.
Brian_K_White 2 days ago [-]
They have to give these silly names to ordinary things. "SinkGhosting is the toxic behavior ruining 46% of relationships..." not doing the dishes.
iberator 2 days ago [-]
Wow I'm in shock, I didn't know until now that there is such a term!!!
I'm using this technique currently, after decades of being super loud, open, known and visible at the workplace.
My whole modus operandi is:
minimum talking = lower probability to get into conflict with coworkers, hr or boss (my job is literally life saver now)
minimum talking = more privacy (I'm homeless for a while and I don't want to talk about my personal problems or anyone to know anything about me, including absolute overkill with skills and education level etching)
minimum talking = they don't fuck with you as they don't know you. They don't know if you are kind or not etc.
It's a shame that it took me 2 decades to understand that some people are silent and avoidant not because they are shy or stupid but as a strategic choice.
Downside: no parties or romantic adventures at work at any cost too. (bye bye numerous beer invitations from hot blue-haired 19yo intern ) .
Works like a charm. Sometimes it's sad and lonely but it's net positive on the long run.
falsemyrmidon 2 days ago [-]
Paywall
2 days ago [-]
jagged-chisel 2 days ago [-]
Sounds like stoicism.
intellectronica 2 days ago [-]
Not really. Stoicism is first and foremost about how you deal with yourself. Gray-rocking is a tactic for dealing with others. I suppose it fits with Stoicism in that dealing effectively with others can be good for you.
stackghost 2 days ago [-]
It’s different in application. Grey-rocking is where you maintain firm boundaries but otherwise refuse to engage in drama.
This has the effect of completely disabling people who thrive on causing drama, or people like my neighbour who only seem to be content when everyone else is making accommodations for her poorly-behaved kid and/or telling her how hard her life must be.
People like that will decide one day that they’re not getting enough attention so they will create situations where they have the opportunity to be offended about $issueDuJour. Grey-rocking prevents them from their parasocial behavior using you as leverage.
Brian_K_White 2 days ago [-]
What a dramatic way to describe not participating in drama.
Give it a name, capitolized even, and exhort to embody being less flappable with all your might.
It's kind of like how religious people can only conceptualize atheism as the atheist religion.
It's goofy.
Next there will be GreyRock Scrum Masters to teach everyone the Principles of not taking invalid things seriously.
What a huge goddamn waste of time that was.
It got to a point that to preserve my sanity at work, I kept my head down, did the work that needed to be done (whether assigned or not), stopped going to meetings I didn't care about, and stayed mostly silent in all others. All the while dreaming of a new career or early retirement. But then a strange thing happened... It turns out that if your reputation is one of quiet confidence, people start to actually listen. They assume that when you do talk, it's only going to be about something important and worth hearing. Instead of co-workers on other teams trying to throw their work over the wall at you, they begin every innocent question with an apology: "hey, I know you're super busy, but I was wondering if I could bug you real quick..." Borderline indifference is so far my favorite superpower that I've accidentally discovered.
Been there once and don't feel like repeating it.
But beyond that I wouldn't use it, I think it creates a boring and stagnant life. What I think is better is to have a few "north stars" and pick your battles. Only pick the fights which bring you closer to your north star and which you have a good shot at winning. Go ahead and pick those with reckless abandon, and when you run out of them you really do just get to turn off, go home, watch some TV, maybe meditate on where you might find more of those battles, but otherwise ignore anything and everyone you feel like ignoring.
This will create a way more interesting and fruitful life than a general policy of being boring in order to be ignored. This is how you carve out a life which is exactly what you want to live, instead of living in reaction to others. Just be smart about when you stick your neck out or spend your energy and attention. Especially in the modern era where attention is the most valuable resource in existence.
It could be different cultures though, I'm from west EU.
The nice thing about this philosophy is that you actually have the time to dig deep into interesting problems because your aren't constantly reacting to other people's demands and deadlines.
One caveat is that you need to have a great manager who understands this work ethic and its benefits.
I don't get these people who just stay Type A HustleBros their entire careers. Like, where are you going, man, and what are you really hoping to get? At some point $SALARY X 1.1 is just not worth the mental toil.
Long-term, it can be hard to sustain, and maybe a bit unhealthy – it becomes a form of self-betrayal, where you repeatedly suppress genuine negative feelings about dealing with someone difficult. These feelings are there for a reason, even if expressing them with the person triggering them would be counterproductive.
Also, in more extreme cases, the sort of people who are prone to creating drama and conflict pick up on the technique and make it into a battle of wills – who will break and give up first. And they may be a lot better at it than you are, because for them it is a central feature of their personality, and for you it's just a tactic for immediate relief.
But he's got a point. Lots of time, we do have a choice. This is especially true online. We know someone is saying/doing crazy things just to get attention, but we still engage, especially when it comes to topics like politics and religion. At that point, I suppose it is more of our fault.
That said, this is unlikely to fully work with colleagues, family, friends. So maybe the always part is not true?
This is all easy in theory, but the difficulty comes in having the discipline to practice...
Put another way, the type of person who is naturally “boring” and not very reactive probably won’t get themselves tangled with the kind of person that needs to be “grey rocked”. If you are always a gray rock, then you are not an easy target for a manipulator.
Maybe it is defensive but it can also be aggressive. For situations where time is on their side, it can really just be a means of handling the situation - there is no reason to think it is only a defence against aggressors. It is ultimately just a manipulation technique.
Perhaps it's a stretch, but I think the policy that Google has in place, where they are notoriously hard to get a response from, is an example of aggressive grey rocking. They have no interest in hearing your possibly justified complaint - if they make it impossible for you to speak, you have no ability to seek redress. Endless complaint procedures are the same thing. Being put on hold for hours also.
If you find yourself in the blast radius of an abusive narcissistic person for example, grayrocking is totally a decent way to deal with them, while keeping your calm. But using it towards everybody whom you're not 100% on board with is probably a bit overkill.
It is unhealthy simply because it's a rebranded form of passive aggression. The real problem is not yet having figured out why someone like that can get under your skin in the first place.
The exact same situations that can bubble up unhealthy amounts of negative emotion in younger people don't do that in older people. Older people have already been there and done that. They fully understand the behavior and instead of anger or retaliation they usually feel pity or nothing at all. Which mind do you think is healthier?
In other words, there's no escaping life's lessons. Your best bet is to minimize the unavoidable consequences and stay out of trouble. For sure, a big part of that is cutting out bullshit like Esquire. This "grey rocking" stuff is just woo woo nonsense that was meant to prime you for ads that already happened back in 2021.
That's the exact definition of "grey rocking." It's a harm minimization technique taught to victims of narcissists who are unable to immediately get away from the narcissist. Examples would be people who must stay in contact because of kids, or someone planning an escape over the course of weeks/months.
I know someone personally in the latter category. "Grey rocking" for the week prior to their escape was indeed "their best bet" and definitely not "woo woo."
It's nonsense.
Grey Rock method worked against a particularly toxic work conflict that was keeping me awake at night... but... the reality was that it produced zero work results for any of us.
I don't know that I'd recommend it. It started as a means to get people to leave me alone, but at some point, it just became who I am. I struggle to get excited about anything or to express strong opinions about things. This makes life very flat. For someone who is living with a bunch of drama, they may look at my life and see it as peaceful, but it is also really mundane. I worry I will get to the end of my life, look back, and realize that I never really lived. But at this point, I've been this way for so long that it's all I really know. I have vague memories as a child of not being like this, but I don't see a path back as an adult.
Proceed with extreme caution.
First, is that grey rocking is a tactical choice, an act. If you've done this since adolescence, it suggests that this is a learned defense mechanism, not a tactical choice. Someone that is truly "grey rocking" has some kind of relatively lively personality that they are suppressing as a tactic. This doesn't sound like what you've described for yourself. That's not to say that you don't have some lively personality in waiting: we all were rambunctious or curious children, and somewhere inside all of us, that child lives.
Second, I would suspect that you grew up in an environment where having needs, showing excitement, or expressing strong opinions drew attack, mockery, or drama. Thus, being boring and expressing no opinions or emotions was a quite valid adaptation to the environment, which persists into adulthood.
The unfortunate trick is that you usually won't start doing various activities that make healthy people happy (socializing and hobbies) and experience the same happiness and joy. The early phase will be that you feel some curiosity, attention or engagement, and perhaps anger and annoyance at the friction in any new or long disregarded experience.
Feeling something is the first step.
For someone who is already an established adult, it may be a different story, especially if it's just for a few months and around one person who has the ability to leave.
I am trying to work on it now, after 20 years of using alcohol as a crutch to feel things and participate socially, which killed all my other hobbies and the social participation over time.
The warning is more for younger readers or those who would need to employ this for years on end, especially through big life transitions. Be careful not to lose yourself in the role.
As far as I understand it, part of how we suppress emotion is that we stop reacting to it, and we stop breathing in accordance with requirements for proper functioning of emotion and emotional reaction. We get lost inside it.
Anyone having these sorts of people problems I would highly recommend https://youtube.com/@DoctorRamani
If you enjoy Ramani, you may also want to read the works of Dr. Lindsay Gibson. She does a great job of guiding people who suffer from having emotionally immature parents, without dehumanizing them. She doesn't even use clinical terms in her books, even though she is a clinical psychologist. The principles are the same even if the people you are struggling with are not your parents.
Ramani specializes in NPD. People with NPD are not able to provide for themselves emotionally so they rely on others, their “narcissist supply”, to which they become dependent. It’s very much like addiction, except instead of abusing a substance, they end up abusing people in order to meet their needs; people become objects and resources instead of being people. That objectification, if not treated, is how narcissism spreads. That’s the great benefit of grey rocking; they aren’t attracted to people who don’t give them energy and will leave them alone. Yellow rocking is a more positive way to interact with the world, but you have to be really good at setting boundaries, otherwise someone with NPD will misjudge polite engagement as a willingness to give them energy. With NPD people, imho it’s more kind to grey rock, as yellow rocking can make them feel rejected, which adds to their trauma. Like addiction, the thing that helps them recover is to be cut off from their supply, so they can learn to provide for their own emotional needs instead of relying on external sources. Very often empathetic people unintentionally end up acting as enablers which causes more harm. Objectification harms the objectifier as well as the person being objectified; if they see others as objects, they internalize that themselves as well, and become the source of their own trauma.
Thanks for the tip, I will check him out.
I will admit that these days I do not consume any material that deals with NPD, because while I found it useful early on to contextualize the behavior of a couple of people who have abused me, it is not my responsibility to either diagnose or treat them. Instead, my attention has shifted to folks like Tim Fletcher and Lindsay Gibson, who elaborate on the path to recovery.
> Like addiction, the thing that helps them recover is to be cut off from their supply
There appears to be quite some debate around whether or not folks with NPD can be treated at all, with only a few therapists seemingly confident that they can genuinely help them, such as Diana Diamond et al.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ZFQG2e87ZU
I do not know where you got the idea of flowcharts. No one mentioned them.
The article takes it too far by treating it as a technique for dealing with difficult situations with normal people. However, the comment you responded to recommends Dr Ramani, who promotes it as a technique for dealing with narcissistic abusers. She also says in one video that its not the diagnosis that matters, it the behaviour that you have to deal with. Do you have a better suggestions for that situation?
Why should anyone care if an abuser finds them a weird human being? Your aim is usually to get away from the relationship, what serves that better than grey rock?
Yes, this is what I am addressing. I clicked and skimmed that YouTube channel and I've seen this type of content recommended before. It is precisely the analytical rabbithole of personality types and flowcharts I was referring to. You are proving my point by using the label "narcissistic abuser".
> Do you have a better suggestions for that situation?
If you judge that interacting with someone is harmful to you, I suggest you simply stop interacting with them. If you are dealing with actual abuse (i.e. unwanted communication after you've expressed your desire to stop communicating, stalking, threats, etc.), there are usually legal steps you can take depending on your jurisdiction.
Why did you insert the [sic]? Do you mean I should properly call her Dr Durvasula? That is pedantic and impedes communication.
> you are proving my point by using the label "narcissistic abuser".
Which part of it do you object to?
Are you saying people should not be labelled abusers? If so, I very strongly disagree.
Are you saying people should not be labelled "narcissistic"? There is an identifiable pattern of behaviour, and techniques for dealing with it. it is useful. I have found it much easier to deal with someone once I dealt with narcissistic behaviour as such, using techniques such as grey rock.
> If you judge that interacting with someone is harmful to you, I suggest you simply stop interacting with them.
Nice simple solution for some! What if you are married to them and living in the same house? There are financial constraints to just moving out. You may have children you need to protect which you cannot do if you leave, unless you take the children with you which itself can be a problem - and that means you have to be sure the courts will take your side if the abuser contests who should have the children.
Even worse, what if the abuser is a parent and you are still a minor? Just stop interacting with someone you are dependant on?
The core of domestic abuse is control and manipulation. Undermining people's self confidence, controlling them financially, or with threats to them and others. Apart from the practical constraints you are doing the equivalent of telling someone with depression to "snap out of it", or someone with PTSD to "man up", etc.
> If you are dealing with actual abuse
You really do not seem to understand the nature of abuse.
> here are usually legal steps you can take depending on your jurisdiction.
For some things, not others. It has to be something that is 1) illegal and 2) something the police and the courts are interested in enforcing.
My experience is that although coercive control is a crime in the UK, the police (and courts) are not interested unless there is evidence of violence, nor in male victims (who also almost always do not have the option of fleeing to a shelter). I have actually been told by the police that they were not interested in even looking at evidence.
From the information I could find, this person has a PhD in psychology, which I deem to be a pseudoscience. Her usage of "Dr" is meant to project an image of authority: most people associate "Doctor" with "medical doctor" i.e. someone qualified to diagnose diseases and prescribe treatments. This person is not a doctor in that sense. She is a counselor/therapist who runs a YouTube channel.
> Are you saying people should not be labelled abusers?
> Are you saying people should not be labelled "narcissistic"?
Yes. I'm very skeptical that labeling people and putting them in these boxes is helpful. It's just horoscopes with the veneer of science. In my experience, almost everyone can display traits that are associated with "narcissism" to various degrees depending on the context (egoism, feeling superior to others, envy, callousness, etc.). And this goes for other "personality types" these psychologists use as a diagnosis. These categories are fuzzy, unstable over time, and often overlapping (is this person a narcissist, a sociopath, or antisocial? Or are they just having a bad day?). Overall, I don't think this ontological zoo of personality types and disorders is very helpful.
> Nice simple solution for some! What if you are married to them and living in the same house? There are financial constraints to just moving out [...] what if the abuser is a parent and you are still a minor?
Depending on the specific situation you are facing, there are procedures for that, such as divorce courts or child protective services. It seems to me that you are seeking some way to indirectly manipulate a person you deem an abuser into behaving in the way you want and you are doing this by guessing how they would behave based on these personality types. Imo, this is weird and inefficient. If communicating your needs directly to the person in question doesn't work, I would seek a more direct route for ending these relationships you deem abusive.
> You really do not seem to understand the nature of abuse
Maybe I don't, no. If you can share, what specifically are you talking about?
Many of the most dubious theories in the area have been devised by psychiatrists who are medical doctors.
So you would never label anyone an abuser? What is someone beats their spouse if they do not do what they are told?
If so, why exclude someone who achieves the same objective through other means? Control of finances, control of children, lies, social isolation, constant yelling and put downs....?
> In my experience, almost everyone can display traits that are associated with "narcissism" to various degrees depending on the context (egoism, feeling superior to others, envy, callousness, etc.). And this goes for other "personality types" these psychologists use as a diagnosis. These categories are fuzzy, unstable over time, and often overlapping (is this person a narcissist, a sociopath, or antisocial? Or are they just having a bad day?).
Yes, there are blurry boundaries, but what I think you do not understand is just how extreme these people are. We all have bad traits, but for most people these are not the dominant elements in our personalities. We are talking about people who are self-centred, manipulative, deceitful, and controlling very extremely and consistently. People who will scream and yell every day, lie to others to make people look bad, use friends and family to put pressure on their spouse (including telling them they are bad), tell they are children they are wicked and stupid daily, and even publicly, do things (real specific example!) like unplug an internet connection to stop their spouse taking part in a zoom call with their family.
Dr Ramani actually addresses the issue of exact labels. She says in one video that a diagnosis does not matter. If you are faced with that sort of behaviour then you use the appropriate ways of dealing with it.
> Depending on the specific situation you are facing, there are procedures for that, such as divorce courts or child protective services.
Do you expect children to be able to ask those services to intervene? I have already pointed out the practical problems with divorce. Divorce and moving out takes time and people have limited options. You grey rock in the meantime. It took me well over an year (and a lot of effort dealing with the courts) from telling my ex-wife I was divorcing her to her actually moving out. Techniques like grey rock help you understand that.
> I would seek a more direct route for ending these relationships you deem abusive.
There are multiple problems with that. Firstly you need to identify the relationship as abusive. We are talking about people who are manipulative and deceitful. The labels help people realise that these people will never change, and how to deal with them. You also need to be able to go through things like the divorce process.
Society discourages people (especially men) from recognising that they are victims of abuse. There are huge pressures to keep a relationship going. People put up with a lot if they think its best for their children. You can face social pressure to keep a relationship going. A lot of people will just brush aside the issue.
I think another thing you underestimate is how years of manipulation and undermining affects people's self confidence and ability to function normally.
After a while they tended not to talk to me at family functions.
I use it when dealing with over-sharers or people who are after a reaction and attention.
I don't know. Sure, if being stalked by your ex is making your life a living hell, maybe this is a better alternative. But I couldn't imagine living like this long term, and I know that I would also lose contact to a friend if they chose to just erase their own personality like that.
But what if grey rocks are not that special? Could it be that a change into anything would bring some degree of improvement? Maybe the actual driver is to change yourself instead of waiting for the world to change? If so, maybe there are better things than grey rocks?
(I myself like Harvey in "Harvey".)
To me it seems like the crux of the technique is "don't engage in drama" but making yourself lesser to do that seems problematic.
It's not making yourself lesser, it's basically "not taking the bait," which is very much a strength, not a weakness.
Grey rocking is variant of the old message board adage about not feeding trolls, the defenders don't lessen themselves, but reduce the opportunity for abuse.
"How's your job?" "About the same. Still just working with computers."
"Any girls in your life?" "Nah not really. Hard to meet people these days."
"What kind of music do you listen to?" "Whatever they play on the radio I guess"
"You go to church?" "When I can"
"Who are you voting for?" "I haven't thought about it too much. Who are you voting for?"
Answer the question but reveal nothing and they have nothing to pry at. Worst case, turn it around and let them talk about themselves for awhile. Throw in a "Uh huh," "Oh man," and "I'd never thought about it like that" every few minutes until it's time to go.
For some people it needs to be extremely forced as its 100% against their nature and internal 'clock'.
It's like force walking when you have been a runner for a decade.
Imagine being forcibly downshifted into lets say working at PizzaHut as it's the only job you can get despite your IT career etc etc.
In order to avoid conflict, shame, drama you learn to just STFU and not reveal nothing personal to protect your sanity and privacy - even when some youngster in the kitchen bragging that he is the king of hackers, or when your boss is talking extreme nonsense that normally would you correct on the spot...
It's like literally being a fucking superman and you NEED to let someone die on your eyes just to keep your cover.
It's NOT easy, but works wonders in the long run.
Edit: Oh lol. I guess you just have to click the captcha. Never seen that in an archive before.
Though it might possibly vary depending where you come from, using cloudflare for dns, what browser plugins in effect, etc.
In hindsight, I understand this is a technique for when escape isn't possible. When you're still in the stage of blaming yourself and them alternately, suppressing your true feelings leads to feeling like you've abandoned yourself and there's nobody safe to talk to. In a sense, it's kind of what some narcissts want you to do - to become meek and obedient, feeling that any criticism you can say to them is undeserved.
It's masking your feelings, behaviors, and especially reactions to be as flat, boring, and neutral as possible. Your mission is to be unremarkable, so they leave you alone.
Walking on eggshells is more of an anxious behavior.
If you find yourself doing this out of self-defence with someone, they're likely a bully and you should do your best to cut them out of your life. Rocks can still be pissed on. Another thing to be wary of is that, if you spend too much time grey rocking, you might become a rock to people who are kind to you.
Bottom line, if you need to "grey rock", you have a problem that might require a better solution.
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VyGsCB-5bgY
Could it be useful if cornered by a predator at a bar, or a technique for dealing with racist grandma you can't otherwise engage with? I guess. But more likely this will be co-opted as an excuse for being unresponsive to their partners, friends, co-workers, etc., shutting down communication exactly when it is most impactful.
Be warned this is NOT a reasonable way to engage with the world. I dread a future where this is normalized into a real world form of ghosting, which is already a terrible trend turning everyone into avoidant turtles.
It is harmful to both parties - they don't know why you avoided them so they can't fix anything, and you lose assertiveness and the ability to handle any level of discomfort. And as a society we grow more and more disconnected until we simply stop breeding, like pandas.
But I agreed, modern society seems to be normalizing these tactics. Instead of encouraging people to do the hard work of behaving in healthy ways.
The article describes a technique for not engaging with "psychopaths and malignant narcissists." You worry that adoption of this technique will lead to the end of the human race.
But as a modus operandi it sounds awful. The amount of people here yearning for a desert of grey rocks is disconcerting.
You don't say
Life is too short to deal with assholes. Even if they’re your parents. Even if they’re the father/mother of your children. The world is vast.
I'm using this technique currently, after decades of being super loud, open, known and visible at the workplace.
My whole modus operandi is:
minimum talking = lower probability to get into conflict with coworkers, hr or boss (my job is literally life saver now)
minimum talking = more privacy (I'm homeless for a while and I don't want to talk about my personal problems or anyone to know anything about me, including absolute overkill with skills and education level etching)
minimum talking = they don't fuck with you as they don't know you. They don't know if you are kind or not etc.
It's a shame that it took me 2 decades to understand that some people are silent and avoidant not because they are shy or stupid but as a strategic choice.
Downside: no parties or romantic adventures at work at any cost too. (bye bye numerous beer invitations from hot blue-haired 19yo intern ) .
Works like a charm. Sometimes it's sad and lonely but it's net positive on the long run.
This has the effect of completely disabling people who thrive on causing drama, or people like my neighbour who only seem to be content when everyone else is making accommodations for her poorly-behaved kid and/or telling her how hard her life must be.
People like that will decide one day that they’re not getting enough attention so they will create situations where they have the opportunity to be offended about $issueDuJour. Grey-rocking prevents them from their parasocial behavior using you as leverage.
Give it a name, capitolized even, and exhort to embody being less flappable with all your might.
It's kind of like how religious people can only conceptualize atheism as the atheist religion.
It's goofy.
Next there will be GreyRock Scrum Masters to teach everyone the Principles of not taking invalid things seriously.
https://youtu.be/oTwV3vG73cU